Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings

Christine B

★★★★★

Let me tell you what! This is such a really good recipe! I only marinated for 4 hours because I was craving this for dinner!! Followed the recipe, it was so easy!! I was worried that it wasn't going to taste right because I only had just a little less Garam Masala than what the recipe called for. I used 5% Fage yogurt and cut the cayenne in half (just in case the Grand was eating here). Served with Afghan rice, Garlic Naan and extra chopped cilantro for garnish. My Husband said this was a 6 out of 5! Will be making this again, soon!
Like (1)
Krystalynn Williams

★★

Followed the directions and my tikka masala is brown and bland. Very sad and disappointed.
Like (1)
Jane Hunt
I just love this recipe so much. Over time Ive added my own stuff. I add tumeric, a dash of cinnamon, a dash of sugar, a dash of ground ginger, a of onion powder and garlic powder. this has taken it to the next level. THANK YOU FOR THIS RECIPE! A small town girl with no indian restaurant in site this makes my husband and I so happy to have this. also, sometimes i marinate the chicken the night before AND make the sauce the night before in a bowl with lid and stick it in the fridge. this makes it insanely easy the next day to prep.... well there is no prep, just cook it while you have naan in the oven and walla!
Like (1)
Hi Julia! I'm excited to make this, I love Indian food and have been craving it for days! I have a question about the steps of cooking the chicken and making the sauce. I am by no means a good cook, so this may be a very stupid question. After I cook the marinated chicken for 5 minutes, do I then add the sauce ingredients directly to the same pan or a separate one? And then combine the chicken later? Thanks!
Like (0)
Hi Kate! After cooking the marinated chicken for 5 minutes, you should add the sauce ingredients directly to the same pan. There should only be one pan used. Hope that helps! :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

I am making this now and the smell is delicious! Looking forward to the taste once completed. Very easy to put together and the instructions are very clear.
Like (0)
Hi I love Chicken Tikka Masala, however when I order it I order it a spice level 8 or 9. Is this one got good heat and if not what is the key to bring up the spice level?
Like (0)
Hi Eric! For you, I'd suggest 3 instead of 1 jalapeno. If you don't have jalapenos, you can substitute with 1/2 teaspoon of red pepper (cayenne) powder and add more to taste while the sauce is simmering.
Like (0)
Mine turned out quite Red! What did I do wrong!? (Sorry if I didn't write things correct! I'm from Holland!)
Like (0)
Hi Saskia! Did you follow my instructions exactly or did you do something differently? Did you use the ingredients that I listed? If you live in Holland, it's possible that some ingredients are sold under different names there.
Like (0)
Sarah Ray

★★★★★

This recipe is amazing!! Im so glad i stumbled across it on Pinterest. Yum!!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Delicious recipe!!! I just made it and I love it! There was quite a bit of marinade, however, when I first was cooking the chicken. Also, the yogurt seemed to separate a bit, the sauce is not completely smooth, is that normal? Thank you! :)
Like (0)
Hi Kris! Yes, it's normal to get a bit of separation in the sauce because of the fat content in the various ingredients. Just stir it up and it'll be smooth again. :)
Like (0)
Claudia Phillips

★★★★★

This is delicious! I made a few adaptions to the recipe. I didn't have enough whipping cream so I used what I had (about 1/3 cup) and a can of full-fat coconut milk. It was delicious and even better left over. This recipe is a keeper.
Like (0)
I have been preparing this dish for about 20 yrs I would change jalapeños for habanero smoother more well rounded heat and a little can go a long way. Also I would not use garam masala gather the spices and add the levels you enjoy for a dish that you can truly appreciate. Also when starting the sauce if have the time fresh grind everything and let the heat of the pan open up those flavors your mouth with come alive.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Thank you so much for sharing this recipe. I tried this dish at a restaurant and had to make it for myself, and your version is just as good or better! Glad I found it. Very easy, too, for a first timer like me making Indian food. (Holy amazing spices! I've never dreamed of such flavor!) Best of all, my husband is now in love with this dish, too. I'm making it again because he's asked for it so many times. Roll in the compliments, please! I can't wait to share with guests. I love a recipe I can count on to please and wow.
Like (0)
I only have whole fat Greek yogurt. Could I use that instead of 2% fat?
Like (0)
I thought before that indian food is strange But i ate it once in a returant and i loved it so much.your recipie is very easy and the ingredient are so simple..thank you.i shall try it soooon.
Like (0)

★★★★★

This recipe was absolutely stunning. Perfect. Unbelievably easy to make. This will be a weekly meal in our house. I'm very interested to try something lighter than heavy cream. If it's even half as irrisistable as this recipe, I'll be thrilled. Thank you!!! My sauce was a bit grainy from all of the spices so next time I'll make it a bit earlier to see if that helps the dissolving.
Like (0)
Love the taste. My color was nothing like chicken tikki masala however. More pinkish than anything. Something i missed?
Like (0)
Another commenter had a similar issue, and pointed out that they had incorrectly bought the wrong kind of garam masala. Maybe that happened to you as well?
Like (0)