Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Is this for a 6 qt IP? I'm having more ppl over and needed like 2 lbs of chicken.
Like (0)
This is for a 6 quart IP. If you have more people coming, simply double the ingredients but keep the pressure cooking time the same.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Yum, Yum!!!! This was my first recipe with my new instant pot!!!! Delicious!!! Couple of things... I added extra spices and a pat of butter during the second sautée mode. Also, I actually marinated the chicken overnight as decided not to make it that night. I think it really added to the flavor as well as the tenderness of the chicken. I have to say, it was good if not better than our go to Indian restaurant!!!! Now I can make it at home. Served it with basmati rice, Naam and sprinkled a little fresh parsley on top as we don’t care for cilantro. Kudos a million times!
Like (0)
Hi! How would you adjust the cooking time if you were using frozen boneless, skinless thighs? We love tikka masala and I just got an Crockpot Pressure Cooker, so I am excited to try this!
Like (0)
Hi Erin! Using frozen is a bit tricky because you need to marinate the chicken before cooking it, and that won't be easy to do if the chicken is frozen. I hope that makes sense. Let me know if I didn't answer your question!
Like (0)
Julia Smith
I was wondering if it is okay to marinate a little longer than 1 hour? I am trying to make this for dinner and start the marinade while kids are napping.
Like (0)
christine kolowith

★★★★

Most recipes I'm used to have a bit more sweetness and I think the cream thinned it out too much at 1 cup. Have you ever tried it with Full-fat coconut milk?
Like (0)
I prefer the texture of the sauce when using heavy cream, but other readers have tried using coconut milk and enjoyed it. Let me know if you give it a try!
Like (0)

★★★★

The cooking times and the types of ingredients are spot on. However, the first time I made this using my Instapot, I followed it exactly and ended up with a very soupy masala. 15 ounces of tomato sauce, 1 cup of heavy whipping cream and all the yogurt that sticks to the chicken in the marinade is wayyy too much liquid for one pound of chicken. I spent a good half hour trying to cook it down with no success. Instead this is what I did was use the same recipe but use 2lbs of chicken and I cut the heavy cream to about 1/4 to 1/2 cup (basically enough to get the color right). I also doubled the spices and lemon but did not double any other liquid ingredients. Then, after it had been done pressure cooking, I let it depressurize naturally for 10 minutes before releasing the quick release valve. When I put it on saute, I added 1-2 tbsp of flour to thicken the sauce. Optional: Use habaneros for heat if you really want to spice it up. I used 2.5 habaneros with seeds diced (replacing the cayenne) for 2lbs of chicken. This gave me a hot but very tasty masala. Remember, this is a cream based sauce, so the heat gets diluted. Medium at an indian restaurant would be about 1 habanero for 2lbs of chicken.
Like (0)
Meredith

★★★★

Made for dinner tonight and it was wonderful! I didn't follow the recipe exactly- I used unsweetened almond milk instead of yogurt in the marinade (I didn't have yogurt) and then only added about 1/4 c of almond milk at the end, instead of cream (which I didn't have either). Definitely adding to my dinner rotation!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Perfect! Delicious!!
Like (0)
Hello, Recipe looks great and I am excited to try. Is the calorie breakdown including the rice, or is that just the chicken itself? Thanks!
Like (0)
Hi Emily, the calorie breakdown does not include rice or naan. If you're looking for a lower calorie option, pair with cooked cauliflower rice which is what I usually do.
Like (0)

★★★★

I have two questions. The yogurt seemed to curdle quite a bit. I used regular Greek yogurt. Could that be the reason? If not, any other thoughts? Second question relates to the second saute. After releasing the pressure I changed to the saute function and selected the low temp. The recipe says, once it has come to Temp, etc. However, the pot was still very hot from the pressure cooking cycle so my sauce was boiling, needless to say, not simmering. Any idea what I did wrong? The flavor was fantastic so I hope to resolve my two issues. Thanks!
Like (0)
I'm not sure what you mean by regular Greek yogurt -- what percentage of fat did you use and was it plain or flavored? It's OK that your sauce was boiling and not simmering, you should get a similar result either way. Glad you enjoyed the flavor :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

My yogurt (Fage full fat) curdles every time. It still works out but from an aesthetic level, I would live for it to be creamier. Any thoughts?
Like (0)
Are you first noticing the curdling effect during the chicken sauteing step? You can try the saute mode on a lower temperature, saute for only a few minutes, and turn it off promptly.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Wow. I made this for the first time today (13 March) and it turned out fantastic! The only substitutes I made were 0% greek yogurt in the marinade (instead of 2%) and heavy cream (instead of whipping cream). For me, there was no curdling or separation of liquids. This meal was flavourful without being overwhelming with tender chunks of chicken. We ate the dish with basmati rice and naan.
Like (0)

★★★★

Awesome recipe. I used bone in skinless chicken thighs for more flavour. (Needs 15 min, not 10). My hubby lived in the Carribean so likes more curry than tikka. I would reduce the garam added for sauce to 2 tsp and sub 2 tsp of curry powder. I tripled the cayenne to make it spicy. Reduce the cream to 1/2 cup. Finally, subbed large can of diced tomatoes, drained, plus 1 Tbsp of tomato paste, cuz i thought I had tomato sauce but didn't!
Like (0)
I only have a 3 quart...do I just halve the recipe? New to Instant Pot!
Like (0)
Addy Tyndall

★★★★★

Made this for a group of friends, and it was INCREDIBLE. Definitely one of my new favorite recipes! I will say that I made it for myself and 3 guys, and it went so fast. If you’re feeding 4 hungry people I would double the recipe.
Like (0)
BRANDI YOUNG

★★★★★

I made this tonight. My husband and 8 year old (picky) son loved it. I served with basmati rice and garlic Naan bread. The recipe was easy to follow, and use of my pressure cooker made preparation quick and painless.
Like (0)