Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings
Thinking of making this tonight. What would you add to make it a spicier dish?
Like (0)
To make it spicier, double the cayenne to 1/2 teaspoon.
Like (0)
Made this tonight for a few friends, and we were all very impressed. Super tasty and very simple to make. I have already shared it with a few people. I have been craving Indian food for a few weeks and it hit the spot. I'm happy to have found this gem and I will be making again in the near future.
Like (0)
Made this last night for friends and it was a huge hit! Can't wait to make it again
Like (0)
WOW! I'm such a noob at cooking, but directions were so easy to follow and it turned out very tasty! Thanks!
Like (0)
You're welcome Audrey!
Like (0)
Just made my first meal in the instant pot. This chicken tikka masala was sooo good! My husband agreed it beat our local Indian restaurant’s. The chicken was so tender and flavorful. I never thought that was possible in just 20 minutes.
Like (0)
We loved it and will make it again. My sauce didn’t turn out as thick as I would have liked. What could I do differently next time? I followed the recipe exactly.
Like (0)
How moist was your chicken before cooking? If a bit damp, pat dry with paper towels. Was there a lot of exuded liquid after sauteing? If so, saute longer to evaporate some of that excess liquid. Also, make sure you're using Greek yogurt. Avoid non-Greek yogurt varieties, which are thinner. Lastly, simmer/boil longer after cooking to reduce the sauce. Hope these suggestions help!
Like (0)
I’m sorry to be dense, but do you just throw away the remaining yogurt with spices (marinade)? I’m wondering if maybe I could stir it in when I put in the cream. What do you think?
Like (0)
Hi Amanda! I typically don't have much leftover marinade, as most of it is stuck to the chicken. But you can certainly stir it in when you add the cream.
Like (0)
Hi, I've made this recipe a few times and it's delicious! My only issue is that I get a BURN warning just as the pot comes to pressure every time. Then I have to release the pressure, take everything out and scrape the pot before starting the cooking process over. Any tips for not getting it to burn?
Like (0)
Do you have a newer Instant Pot? Some of the newer models have been programmed with a more sensitive burn indicator. You can dilute the tomato sauce with a bit of water to reduce the likelihood of the burn warning.
Like (0)
My 12 yr old just made this! She is in love!! Her and her sister are now planning Thanksgiving Dinner!!
Like (0)
Haha that's amazing! I'm impressed that a 12 year old was able to make it :)
Like (0)
Cooked this for the first time tonight and was not disappointed! Will definitely do it again as it was so good 😁
Like (0)
This was delicious! As good, if not better than you get in the restaurant! Probably needed a little more cayenne :)
Like (0)
Hi, is there a way to make this less spicy- hot?
I like the flavors but when I made mine it turned out a bit too spicy-hot for my liking. Do I just decrease the cayenne pepper next time?
Like (0)
That's correct. Reduce or omit the cayenne altogether.
Like (0)
Can you use coconut milk or cream instead of heavy whipping cream?
Like (0)
I haven't personally tried that, but other readers have and liked the result.
Like (0)
Holy smokes this was delicious!! I was pressed for time and my chicken breasts were frozen so I literally covered the frozen breasts in the maranade, poured the sauce over (without the cream) and cooked in my Instant Pot for 15 minutes. I took out the chicken and shredded it into large chunks, added the cream and voila done! Yes the sauce was much thinner than yours, but for being super fast it was SO delicious! I can’t wait to make it again and actually follow the directions! :-)
Like (0)
Fantastic!! I love how you were able to tweak the recipe, with great results. Thanks for sharing, Penny, and hope you get to make it again.
Like (0)
How’s come my sauce did not come out orange looking like the pic above? It came out just tan looking even though I followed all the instructions above. What could have gone wrong?
Like (0)
Double check the amounts of spices that you're using. Could also be the brand you're using. Another thing you can try is sauteing the chicken longer until more of the chicken juices have evaporated -- sometimes the released chicken juices can contribute to a browner-looking sauce. Hope that helps, Linda.
Like (0)