Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings

★★★★★

I love this dish and have made it many times now. However, the spice level is low in my opinion, does anyone have anything they do to make it spicier?
Like (0)

★★★★★

Thank you so much for this recipe. Chicken tikka masala is in my top three favorite dishes and I made this last night it was wonderful just like at a restaurant and it was so simple to make. I already had everything on hand except for the coriander in which I had ground coriander and it still came out wonderful! The only thing I did different was that I already had yogurt marinated chicken breast that I broiled in the freezer that I keep for my keto diet and also I added an extra half cup of heavy cream to the sauce it made it taste more like the creamier authentic chicken tikka masala and less like Curry chicken or butter chicken that I'm used to from restaurants. And I also put one packet of splenda naturals in the sauce to cut down on some of the acidity and Bam! That really did the trick. I couldn't stop eating it but I had to it was so delicious! I just couldn't have my naan bread and my basmati rice 😞but it still deserves more than five stars to me! 😀
Like (0)
Cilantro is not coriander. Coriander is dried cilantro seed pods. The flavor is much different.
Like (1)
How could I do this recipe with already cooked chicken breast chunks??
Like (0)
kukunariss

★★★★★

what happens to the marinade once the chicken goes to searing? do I use it or do I only need the meat and sauce? I did the recipe once and it was delicious but I wasn't sure about the marinade thing, I'd appreciate if you could let me know :)
Like (0)
I'm not exactly sure what you're asking. Since the chicken chunks are coated in thick marinade, that means that the chicken chunks are seared with the marinade on them. You don't remove the marinade from them -- that would be messy and hard to do. Any excess marinade (usually not much) left in the marinating bowl can be discarded or later incorporated into the sauce while it's simmering. Does that answer your question? If not, let me know how I can elaborate further.
Like (2)
Looking for ways to prep ahead of time. Could I sear the chicken the day before and refrigerate, then cook in sauce the next day?
Like (0)
Yes, I think that would work nicely. You should also be able to make everything ahead of time. In my experience, leftovers reheat well on the stovetop as well as in the microwave.
Like (1)
Renata Hadden
I want to make this recipe however I can’t have heavy whipping cream can I sub it for something else?
Like (0)
Can I make this without Fage yogurt? Why is this yogurt different?
Like (0)
Use yogurt that is Greek style (because they are much thicker than regular yogurt, making it a more effective marinade that easily coats the chicken chunks). It doesn't have to be the Fage brand; I mention it because that's the brand that I use and have tested this recipe with. I also haven't found any other yogurt brands besides Fage in my local stores that are Greek style, plain unflavored, and not the nonfat kind.
Like (1)
Julez1961

★★★★★

I have made this recipe a lot, it's easy and tastes delicious. I can't wait to eat it again tonight. I use any leftovers in puff pastry, just cut a sheet of pastry in 4 and put some of the leftovers on a half of the sheet, fold and crimp the sides, and freeze or eat as a Sunday snack. Delicious!
Like (0)

★★★

How did you get the light color in the end if you slightly charred the chicken in the beginning? There is always some char left in the bottom of the skillet after the chicken is done and it ends up mixing into the sauce somewhat. Also, I meant to give this 4 stars since it is pretty good. Mine just turned out darker even though I followed the directions to a T.
Like (0)
It sounds like your chicken is overly charred; note that the instructions in Step 3 state "Cook for a few minutes until they are golden brown and a bit charred." The chicken can go quickly from golden brown to overly charred, so transfer them to a plate promptly to avoid this issue. Another thing to pay attention to is the fact that I use a nonstick pan (Step 3). If you used a stainless steel pan, the chicken and its marinade will easily stick to the pan and burn.
Like (0)
Erika Trinidad

★★★★★

Absolutely delicious! Thank you for the recipe Julia!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Omg so good! Love Indian food but have never made any and after searching and searching, I chose this one based off of the comments alone! Basically followed this recipe to the t with the exception of adding a bit more spice with red pepper flakes and a Thai spice blend I had on hand. Delicious and so easy! Will definitely make this again!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Absolutely delicious!!
Like (0)