Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings

Got my chicken marinating in the fridge for my dinner tomorrow! My first ever attempt at a curry and I'm very much looking forward to it. Will substitute the cream for coconut milk and adding onions just to make it a bit healthier. After reading everyone's comments, I have high hopes! 🤞🏼 thank you for sharing the recipe 🙂
Like (0)
This recipe is so great! The sauce is fantastic and I like to double it so I have a lot leftover and I can use it over rice or veggies for the rest of the week. One thing I’ve found is sometimes my chicken turns out rubbery. I follow the recipe exactly every time so I’m not sure why this happens and I would love if you had some pointers on how to deter that.
Like (0)
Here are some ideas: (1) Don't sear the chicken as long as you have been. And once they're seared, immediately transfer to a plate. Use lower heat, too. These small changes may help by avoiding overcooking the chicken. (2) Are you using the same brand of chicken every time? Things like the supplier of chicken and if it was previously frozen could be the issue. (3) Try boneless skinless chicken thighs instead. They're less likely to overcook, which is usually the reason why you get rubbery tasting chicken. Hope that helps!
Like (0)

★★★★★

This is my new go to recipe. Guests rave about it and hubs regularly asks for it.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I LOVE making this dish! Thank you so very much for the recipe, it is excellent! I cheat quite a bit and throw all the chicken in the pan (and usually a double serving because I can eat on it for days) and add the sauce ingredients directly with the chicken. Saves me a plate to clean which I always try to do :)
Like (0)
Stephanie

★★★★★

This was a good recipe! I made it as suggested since it was the first time. I doubled the recipe exactly and went for more cayenne based on the recommendation. I doubled the cayenne and would personally still call that "medium" lol, but I like heat. The only thing is, it did not turn out this creamy orange color. Mine was more brown, I'm not sure why. Super creamy and very rich though. Next time I would probably use a higher ratio of tomato sauce and swap a tad of the cream for chicken broth, however it was good as-is and I would probably reference this recipe again even if I tweaked it. I paired it with a keto-friendly naam recipe I found and it was a great meal. I'd like to request a naan recipe though haha. What I used was more like a naan biscuit, based off of a fathead dough. It was good, but I'd love something better!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I’ve made this recipe several times now and it’s a favorite go to! Delicious in flavor and beautiful color. Thank you for sharing! Making it tonight per daughter’s request!
Like (0)

★★★★★

This was so simple and so comparable to takeout! We loved it, new favorite at home dish!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Absolutely delicious!!! Not many dishes could compare in flavour to this recipe.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I have made this recipe a bunch and love it!! Planning on making it this week but I have a tub of nonfat plain yogurt that I don’t want to go to waste. Could I use that in place of the Greek yogurt?
Like (0)

★★★★★

Oh my is this recipe so AMAZING! I took some in to work for a coworker, and she said it was like I got it at an authentic Indian restaurant! It is the best recipe I have found for tikka misala! I love it so much and will be making it part of my monthly meal plans for sure!
Like (0)
Kathleen

★★★★★

I followed this recipe exactly like is and it was amazing! The whole family loved it! I will definitely be making again. Thank you!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I love this recipe. Use it all the time, but I am having a hard time finding a naan bead that I love. Any you would recommend?
Like (0)
If you're based in the U.S., I like Stonefire's naan (https://www.stonefire.com) and I get it at my local Kroger grocery store. They taste great and are easy to reheat.
Like (0)
Halfbaked harvest on Pinterest has a good naan recipe! I’d just type Halfbaked harvest naan in the search bar :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

Household favorite (even my daughter) for a few years now! So good! I think you used to have a diced jalapeño in this recipe? Either way, I add it and it adds some good spice to it
Like (0)
Ariel Mayo
can you substitute coconut milk for the heavy whipping cream??
Like (0)
Does anyone know if I can substitute the greek yogurt with either cream cheese or soft goat cheese???
Like (0)