Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings
I quadrupled this recipe to feed my small group of 20 people and it was a huge hit! Perfect amount of spice and very creamy and delicious. Went great with rice and naan! I will definitely make it again and got asked for the recipe so many times!
Like (0)
This is the BEST recipe. Every time I make it, it’s perfect and taste like it was made at a restaurant.
Like (0)
Is this too spicy? Can I reduce the amount of garam masala?
Like (0)
Oh how we love this recipe. We've been making it for a few years now in my household. Every time I ask what to make for dinner for the week, my son, husband, or step daughters request it. This recipe cant be matched (I have tried others.) This one is just perfect.. every time.
Now if you'll excuse me... it is dinner time!
Like (0)
As with all of Savory Tooth's recipes, this was delicious. I added turmeric (the IP recipe has turmeric but this one doesn't?) and a little onion powder at the end after tasting the sauce. I also ended up taking out the chicken and reducing the sauce a bit more because I like it really thick. Didn't want to over cook the chicken. There is so much sauce and I LOOOOVE THAT!
I left out the cayenne and I'm glad I did because my garam masala had a serious kick to it. I used smoked paprika instead of reg because it's so good.
Served it over roasted cauli rice. Would be TO DIE FOR over basmati!!! Thanks again for all of your gorgeous recipes. Your directions are always really clear.
Like (0)
My husband is Indian and he only ever orders this dish at Indian restaurants, he LOVED this recipe. So so good!! But his mom is vegetarian so I'm wondering, do you have any vegetarian suggestions instead of chicken??
Like (0)
Yes, I think cauliflower, potato, or chickpeas would work well. Here's a similar version I made using roasted cauliflower: https://www.savorytooth.com/cauliflower-curry/
Like (1)
Can you freeze the leftovers? It was amazing and I would love to take to my daughters when we visit
Like (0)
I've made many variations of tikka masala in search of a taste I enjoyed in Bangalor. This recipe is a good one and I think using tomato sauce is the secret (not fresh tomatoes). I made a couple minor changes to meet my taste... I fried a tejpata (Indian bay leaf) in the pan with oil until it got dark before adding the sauce, added a little fresh shredded ginger, and cut back on the cream by a third. Delicious!
Like (0)
For anyone wondering, I made this dairy free with cashew yogurt and coconut milk. As it turns out, I don't particularly love the flavors of either and so I added a whole bunch more of the dry seasonings (including the addition of garlic powder, cause I was so done with cutting garlic).
Anyway, as someone that's only had this from Trader Joe's (but that may have been Butter Chicken) I was happy! Indian food is not something I'm well-versed in, nor making things dairy free, but for some reason I made this and it was a delicious dinner!
Like (0)
I made this tonight and it turned out well. The chicken (I used boneless, skinless thighs) was tender. I marinated it all day. Next time, I would use a better, thicker tomato sauce as the taste was too bright for me. Also, the garam masala I used had too much cinnamon for my taste.
Do you have any suggestions for good garam masalas or tomato sauces to try?
Thanks!
Like (0)
I use Pinch Spice Market garam masala. Only garam masala I'll use. I've had garam masala with too much cinnamon ruin my food before too.
Like (0)
I've used this recipe over and over again! It's a keeper for sure!!! I do have trouble coming up with a vegetable to serve with it. A creamed spinach would be common... but I don't love it... looking for other suggestions.
Like (0)
I am not much of a cook, but I have been wanting to make this for awhile. I finally made it tonight. The recipe was easy to follow and not difficult at all. Best of all, it was delicious! My son thinks it amazing, too. We will definitely be making this again (and again, and again).
Like (0)
This is my go-to tikka masala recipe and I am making it tonight!
Like (0)
We love this dish! This is our go-to recipe for Indian night. Thank you so much for sharing.
Like (0)
Can you please tell me what specific tomato sauce you use for this recipe?
Thanns
Like (0)
I typically use a store brand tomato sauce. For example, Kroger brand tomato sauce can if you live in the U.S.
Like (0)
This recipe sounds so delicious, but I recently found out I’m allergic to ginger. I love ginger, but alas, it doesn’t like me. Any ideas for a substitute for ginger?
Like (0)
Hi Dorene. I would just omit the ginger without substitution.
Like (0)
This recipe es fantastic, we absolutely loved it.
Like (0)
Hi - so, you would use regular yogurt ( NOT greek) in Chicken tikka! It does not make the marinade watery, esp if you use full fat. Also, the chicken will not get a sear/char, since it has the yogurt marinade. Better option is to broil it for a few minutes on each side, to partially cook it. I see that you are in Boston - interesting. I am as well (boston area) and teach very popular cooking classes ( My take out Indian restaurant faves def includes a fabulous chicken tikka masala!)
Like (0)
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Which are your favorite Indian restaurants in Boston?
Like (0)
I've tried a few recipes like this, but this one is by far my favorite for chicken tikka masala. Thank you for sharing this recipe!
Like (0)
I had been looking for a recipe for Chicken Tikka Masala for a while wanting to find a great recipe and this recipe certainly is delicious. It’s a super easy recipe. I have to admit, I didn’t think I could make it. My family loved it! I give this recipe 5 stars because it’s tasty with a tiny hint of heat enough for someone who can’t eat spicy food. I’m thrilled to have made it! Thank you!
Like (0)