Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings

★★★★★

I just made this and it was delicious. However, mine did not have an orange color it was more of a reddish brown. What did I do wrong?
Like (0)
It could be due to the brand of spices that you used, in particular, garam masala and paprika. Note that the color also changes to a more orangish hue the longer you simmer it. I'm glad it still turned out delicious though!
Like (0)
I typically use the brand "Simply Organic" for garam masala, and I've also used Trader Joe's branded spices. The linked Amazon pages in the recipe are also good. If you make this again, I would suggest measuring chicken, yogurt, and tomato sauce by weight, instead of volume. Are you using defrosted chicken breasts? Sometimes they can be a bit moist or wet -- pat them dry with paper towels before mixing with the marinade. You may also want to use hotter heat or saute the chicken longer so the pan is drier. And double-check your measurements of the other ingredients, especially spices. I hope that's helpful, and that you get a chance to make this again!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I printed the recipe 2 months ago and at that time it said 2 cups cream. Now it says 1 1/5 cups. Did you change that?
Like (0)
Hi Tara! That's correct. I made a few adjustments and the biggest one was less cream. The original recipe with 2 cups yielded a disproportionately large amount of sauce, and in my tests I preferred the version with 1 1/2 cups cream. The current recipe on the site still makes a ton of sauce, in case you're worried about that. Whether you use 1 1/2 or 2 cups, it won't make a big difference in the end result :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

This was amazing. My house smelled so good. I took a gamble and made this recipe for the first time when we had guests over. It was a big hit with them and also with my wife and kids.
Like (0)
Yay, that's so good to hear! This dish definitely does wonders in terms of making my home smell great :)
Like (0)
Fresh ginger over the ground spice!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Beautiful recipe. Authentic taste, rich, and comforting. I simmered for an hour, and added broccoli in the last ten minutes.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I’ve made this recipe so many times. I’m making it again tonight! My family loves it. It’s the PERFECT recipe; tastes even better than the tikka masala I used to get at my favorite Indian restaurant. I use basmati rice and naan from Trader Joe’s and it’s consistently awesome. Thank you!
Like (0)
OHMYGOODNESS!!! This was AHmazing!!! Everyone in the family loved it! FIVE STARS!!!!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Incredibly simple, light and tasty. I couldn't believe it.
Like (0)
Dear Julia, As a new cook, I was a little timid to try this Tikka Masala dish. I can't tell you how happy I am that I did! I have made this about three times now, and every time it is easy, delicious, and basically fool proof. It has become a staple in my household, and my husband begs me to make it. Thank you so much for sharing!! I will be checking out your other recipes.
Like (0)
Christina

★★★★★

This is my favorite tikka masala recipe! Any ideas on how to make it with chickpeas instead of chicken? I want to make a vegetarian version this week.
Like (0)
Hi Christina! I've made a vegetarian version of this with cauliflower: https://www.savorytooth.com/cauliflower-curry/. You might be able to replace that with chickpeas.
Like (0)
Blair Mace

★★★★★

Absolutely delicious.
Like (0)
It's mildly spicy. If you can't handle spicy foods, I suggest skipping the jalapeno or using less cayenne.
Like (0)
Jennifer Ngo

★★★★★

This was delicious! I made this for my kids - my little girl is a chicken tikka masala connoisseur (she orders it EVERY time at EVERY Indian/Pakistani restaurant). She declared this a winner and had 3 servings! I tried the stove top version this time, but will make the slow cooker version next time. Thank you for sharing this recipe with us!
Like (0)