Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings

★★★★★

The perfect recipe! I can't get enough of it!Thank you for sharing!
Like (0)
Hoping to attempt tonight, but only have frozen thighs on hand. Should I thaw chicken first?
Like (0)

★★★★

This was an excellent dish to make. We live 3 hours from the nearest Indian restaurant and this cured our cravings.
Like (0)
Lara power in
My sauce hasn't thickened what should I do?
Like (0)
It should thicken a bit. If the sauce has been simmering for at least 20 minutes, I would consider it done even if it doesn't look particularly thickened.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I made this last night for my fiancé’s birthday. Everyone loved it! I don’t have much experience with cooking Indian food, but this was simple enough to make. As others said, it makes a lot of sauce, so definitely have something to dip such as naan or paratha. I used the whole jalapeño (scraped out the seeds), and it wasn’t too hot for me. (I’m normally a wimp with spice). Thank you for this recipe!
Like (0)
Samantha
This was my first attempt at making any kind of Indian food and this recipe is amazing. My husband and I loved it! Will make again soon!
Like (0)
Hi! This recipe looks great but I’m curious if I could marinate the chicken overnight? I work and marinating for an hour means I won’t i wont till 8 or 9! :(
Like (0)
Jennifer
Unfortunately this dish did not live up to my expectations... The sauce was very thick and grainy from the spices, and did not taste much like chicken tikka masala. I am wondering how to make the sauce less milky and grainy. The sauce also was more of a light creamy orange color, not the typical color of chicken tikka masala? I followed the recipe exactly, but sadly was disappointed. Was hoping this one would be a winner!
Like (0)
IT WAS DELICIOUS!! it was just like the masala i get at a local pakistani restaurant….now, to find a naan bread recipe i like
Like (0)
Hi, I am making this recipe right now for my boyfriend. I am a vegetarian and would like to make a separate dish with tofu. Do you think I can do it the same way? Or should I just cook separate sauce and throw in some baked tofu? Either way I’m fine with, wondering what you think! Do you have a favorite naan recipe? Sorry if these questions were already covered. Thanks!
Like (0)
Hi Sara, how did things turn out? I would recommend cooking separate sauce and throwing in your baked tofu, instead of making it the same way. Hope your boyfriend enjoyed the dish!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I love making this dish, and this my go-to recipe from Pinterest when making it. I like to marinade chunks of zucchini with my chicken and cook it as well!
Like (0)
I love how you include zucchini! That sounds delicious, thanks for sharing your feedback :)
Like (0)

★★★★

I thought the flavors we're very good. I doubled the recipe and substituted the whipping cream for a dairy free alternative but it was still delicious. I would say it was a little too much sauce for me. I doubled and used triple the meat (36oz). After about 30 minute of simmer I'd say to use less tomato sauce and cream next time.
Like (0)
Do you use any oil or ghee when you sauté the chicken?
Like (0)
I don't, and I haven't found that to be necessary. BTW I use a nonstick pan, about 10 inches in diameter with high sides, in case that's helpful.
Like (0)
Christina

★★★★★

I made this for dinner and it was excellent! Wonderful flavors! I used only a cup of cream and added a little water and cornstarch to thicken it. I will be making this again! Thank you!
Like (0)
You're welcome, Christina! Glad to hear you enjoyed it and were able to make adjustments to the sauce :)
Like (0)
Zoy Kocian

★★★★★

I too love Tikka Masala but have had mediocre success making it on the past. I made your recipe last night and my daughter said it was one of the best recipes I’ve ever made. My house smelled amazing for hours like an Indian kitchen. I thought it was a little pale when I first added the cream but the longer it simmered the redder it got. I served it with cauliflower rice and extra chopped jalapeños.
Like (0)
That's fantastic! I love it when my house smells like an Indian kitchen :) I'm so happy to hear your daughter said it was one of the best recipes you've ever made!
Like (0)