Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings

Mandy Mills

★★★★

Hi there, Tried this recipe for the instant pot and absolutely loved it! I love it so much, I'd like to make the sauce and gift it to a few friends of mine. How long do you think the sauce will keep in the fridge? One week? Or do you think I can freeze it? Thanks for your help!
Like (0)
I'm glad you loved the sauce Mandy! :) I think the sauce will be fine for at least half a week in the fridge. I'm a bit skeptical of freezing it because of the dairy component. Let me know if you give it a try!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I absolutely love this dish! Great find on Pintrest! I am looking forward to learning to make more East Indian dishes. Thank you for sharing this great recipe:)
Like (0)
Do you know if this freezes well? I am the only one eating this and, although I love it, don’t want to be eating this for a week straight!
Like (0)
I haven't tried freezing this -- it usually gets eaten too quickly for that :). If you freeze it, I would suggest thawing using your microwave's defrost option or at 50% power.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I adore this recipe!!! This is definitely one of my go-tos, and makes enough that I have a ton of leftovers. I do add some green onions right at the very end of cooking in order to give it a little bit of texture. Love, love, love this!!!!
Like (0)
Jessica Shuler

★★★★★

I can’t wait to make this, but I need a dairy free sub for the yogurt. I can’t have dairy right now because of my sensitive nursling. Can I use coconut milk with vinegar or lemon juice?
Like (0)
Coconut milk mixed with vinegar or lemon juice will be too thin compared to a yogurt marinade. Check if your supermarket sells dairy free yogurt. Silk has an almond based dairy-free yogurt, Stonyfield has a soy based one, and So Delicious sells a coconut based one.
Like (0)
I have found that evaporated milk works well as a substitute for heavy cream
Like (0)

★★★★★

Just made this for my family. My 2 adult sons loved the flavor and the slight burn that comes at the end. The sauce is abundant and marries well with rice or cauliflower. Sending the link for the recipe to my son and his girlfriend. Delicious
Like (0)

★★★★

I made this last week and I used a small jalapeno but put the whole thing in and it was seriously waaay too spicy for me. I could hardly eat it, and my mouth was on fire the whole time so I couldn't enjoy how tasty it was. I am a wuss about spiciness in general, but I can eat reasonably spicy foods (I feel like where I live everyone loves spicy food), but I should have substituted for cayenne or just used nothing at all.
Like (0)
Sorry to hear that! Did you remove the seeds of the jalapeno? That's where most of the capsaicin is.
Like (0)
I definitely did! I scraped that baby raw. And it's fine, I am definitely going to make the "mild" version again lol.
Like (0)
Was wondering if I can marinate for longer than 1 hour, like the day before? Just trying to cut on time. Can’t wait to try it, love chicken tikka Masala! Hope this is as good as the one I had at an Indian restaurant not too long ago. Thanks!!
Like (0)

★★★★★

This was delicious! Made just as directed. Will probably add another pepper next time, was a bit mild, but good flavor overall.
Like (0)
Holly Littke

★★★★★

Made this for dinner tonight and it was soooo good! My only question is when I take the chicken out of the marinade most of the yogurt stuck to the chicken, it was really think Greek yogurt. Should most of the marinade end up in the pot with the chicken or was mine just too thick?
Like (0)
That sounds normal, the marinade should be thick and most of it should end up sticking to the chicken. Glad you liked it :)
Like (0)
Hey! Going to try this sounds delicious, but was wondering to cut calories if I could make it with light coconut milk versus the heavy cream? I know you mentioned I could use coconut milk but I want to use light coconut milk instead and was wondering how this would affect the recipe? Thanks!
Like (0)
I haven't tried that before so I don't know for sure, but I'm guessing it would make the sauce thinner but still flavorful. If you don't mind a thinner sauce, then I say go for it! Also, another way to cut calories is to use only 1 cup of cream/coconut milk.
Like (0)
Please help. I used regular yogurt and it’s thin . I tripled the recipe and there is a lot of yogurt. Should I add all that to the pan?
Like (0)
Regular yogurt doesn't work, you need Greek yogurt for a thick marinade. Don't add your extra yogurt marinade to the pan, only the marinade sticking to the chicken.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Seriously so easy and so flavorful! My husband went back for thirds!!!
Like (0)