Comments on Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
319 comments · 4.90 / 5 from 123 ratings
I plan to make this tonight for dinner, and was wondering if marinating for 7 hours would be too long? I was hoping to prep and marinate it now, but if it should only marinate for 1 hour, I will hold off.
Can't wait to try it!
Like (0)
7 hours is fine. Hope you love the dish and let me know if you have any other questions!
Like (0)
Shortly after sending you this, I got called into the hospital. Didn't even have time to prep the marinade!! Will be trying it another night this week, and will comment with how it goes...thank you!
Like (0)
Thanks for letting me know! Hope you get a chance to try it out next week :)
Like (0)
Oh my gosh...this truly was fantastic! My boyfriend wouldn't let me throw away the leftover sauce..he's currently having it over rice for lunch!!
I'll be trying this next with sweet potatoes, as I also love sweet potato masala!
Thank you for this!!
Like (0)
Hi Jessyca, I'm so glad you guys loved it! Isn't the sauce just amazing? :) Sweet potatoes would go so well with this!
Like (0)
I can't figure out how to give you 5 stars but this recipe is so deicious I just have to try!!! Hoping I can find the ratings spot to tell your readers how absolutely phenomenal this tikka is, and SO EASY!!
Follow the istructions. Don't ad lib. Don't be that guy who says "I don't like spice so I used potatoes instead of jalapenos, and I ran out of yoghurt so I substituted kale and I don't understand why my tikka is lumpy and bland but it must be the writer's fault."
Follow the recipe and enjoy crazy-positive feedback from friends and family who think this recipe is divine. Whip up some 30-minute naan to go with and they'll think you are a goddess.
Like (0)
Hey Suann, I'm so glad you loved it!! Thanks for the kind words and your review :)
Like (0)
Making for tonight. I.usualy order mind so I'm wondering if I should do half or maybe less of jalapeno. Suggestions from other mild eaters that made this?
Like (0)
Hi Whit, you can definitely use just half of a jalapeno, and it should still taste great!
Like (0)
I used half a jalapeno also, I'm a pansy when it comes to spice! Making this again tonight, we love it!!
Like (0)
Hi Julia,Can i add Gold potatoes?If yes at which step? Thanks!
Like (0)
Yes, potatoes would be a delicious addition. You should cook the potatoes first using your preferred method -- boiling or pan frying -- until tender and then set them aside on a plate. Then follow the recipe as usual. Once the sauce is done, add the potatoes back in and stir together. Should be tasty :)
I also have a potato curry recipe that's vegetarian and doesn't have chicken. The sauce is very similar to this one. Here's the recipe: https://www.savorytooth.com/easy-weeknight-potato-curry/
Like (0)
My husband is not very adventurous when it comes to food and he loved this! Made it for him about a week and a half ago and he's already wanting it again. I made mine with a whole jalapeno and it was wonderful despite the fact that I'm not big on spice. As long as the seeds are taken out, I'm not sure 1 jalapeno would be too much spice for anyone (I'm seriously a wuss haha). I was curious though if there was a way to modify this and make it in a crockpot?
Like (0)
Hi Allison! I'm glad to hear your husband loves this dish. I have tried converting this recipe to a crockpot version and it's just not the same, so I don't recommend it. The chicken really needs to be sauteed first, which a crockpot can't do.
If by any chance you have an Instant Pot (or other pressure cooker) and prefer to use that instead, here's the recipe for it: https://www.savorytooth.com/instant-pot-chicken-tikka-masala/
Let me know if you have any other questions. :)
Like (0)
I’ve made this several times now. My favorite pin! It’s very close to the Tikka masala I love from a local place. My only changes are more chicken (I love the amount of sauce but I also love having leftovers so more chicken is required for me), and I do a dash of cayenne in place of the jalapeño. I feel I have more control over the level of spice that way.
I also have both rice AND naan with it. Trader Joe’s has perfect naan in the frozen section. Making it all tonight and I can’t wait! Thanks for the awesome recipe.
Like (0)
Just finished making this for tonight’s dinner. Might I add that I’ve never tried Tikka Masala at a restaurant but I’ve heard great things. I like searching for new recipes when I feel like my usual cycle of recipes is running dry—this has made it in my recipe collection! My boyfriend is very timid when it comes to trying new food but he went up for seconds and seemed to enjoy it (unless he was just being nice). This was very delicious—I made it with only about 3/4 of a jalapeño and it was perfectly spicy for me. I also used jasmine rice because that’s what I had on hand and it was still yummy. However I think I will try some naan to pick up the extra sauce next time. This was great and I’ll be letting my sisters know about this recipe so they can give it a try. Thanks for the yummy dinner!
Like (0)
Glad you enjoyed it, Katie :) I've found that chicken tikka masala is the kind of dish that everyone loves, even those who say they don't like curries or Indian food in general.
Like (0)
This was amazing!! I haven’t had much Indian food, but have liked what little I’ve tried. My husband wanted me to try making this and it was a huge hit! I followed the directions exactly and it turned out perfect. Thanks for sharing such an easy delicious recipe! I will definitely be making this again.
Like (0)
Thanks Elizabeth, I'm so glad to hear you liked it!
Like (0)
I’ve made both versions, regular and hot pot and for some reason my spouse and I both preferred the conventional method. It was very easy to make and very tasty, will make again for sure Indian cuisine is one of my favourite.
Thanks!
Like (0)
Awesome! Thanks for the feedback Louise :)
Like (0)
This recipe looks amazing...I am wondering what modifications I need to make in order to cook this in the slow cooker?
Like (0)
Hi Erin! I actually have a recipe on the slow cooker version that's going to be published this coming Thursday. Here it is: slow cooker chicken tikka masala
Like (0)