Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings
When I made this dish, I was surprised that the marinade called for 1 teaspoon of black pepper. I thought that was a lot. But having never made this dish before, I put it in. I did however, cut back the cayenne in the sauce because I was making it for my kids. The dish would have been awesome because the chicken was tender and the sauce set up perfectly, BUT it was way too spicy. It smelled great and I could tell how flavorful it would have been without the black pepper dominating the dish. I saved the rest for my husband who was out-of-town but who loves spicy dinners! I will definitely make it again for my family, but with WAY less black pepper. Thanks for the recipe!
Like (0)
Thanks for the feedback! It's definitely possible that I love pepper more than the average person :)
Like (0)
I noticed The black pepper only goes in the marinade. Did you add the leftover marinade or discard the marinade. That could make a difference
Like (0)
I don't add the leftover marinade; I only add the marinade sticking to the chicken. I agree, it could make a difference!
Like (0)
What can I use to make it dairy free?
Like (0)
Use coconut cream or coconut milk instead of heavy whipping cream. Also use coconut or almond based dairy-free yogurt instead of Greek yogurt.
Like (0)
Would you use the same amount of coconut milk? 1 cup?
Like (0)
Yes, I would use the same amount. It won't be as thick as heavy cream, but the sauce will still taste great.
Like (0)
Is this dish spicy? If it is then how do I make it not spicy and still good?
Like (0)
Skip the cayenne so it's not spicy.
Like (0)
Ok perfect. thank you. I will try it soon
Like (0)
I haven't made this recipe, but I want too. Can this recipe be done using lamb instead of chicken?
Like (0)
I haven't tried making this with lamb so I can't say for sure. It might work out, but you'll probably have to tweak the cooking time.
Like (0)
Any issue with marinading monger, like up to 24 hours? Then I could do the prep the night before & just pop it in to cook night of...?
Like (0)
I haven't tried marinating that long but I think it'll be totally fine. Let me know how it goes!
Like (0)
Do you think it would freeze well? If we don’t eat all of it all at once?
Like (0)
Sorry I haven't tried freezing it so I can't say for sure. It should last in the fridge for at least a few days.
Like (0)
This recipe look great, but I am unable to' pin it' as the desription is 514 characters and only 500 characters are acceptable. I did bookmark it, so I can try it.
Like (0)
Thanks for letting me know! I think I fixed the problem, can you try pinning it again?
Like (0)
Can't wait to try this! Can I make this with a white fish? What changes would need to be made to pressure cooking time?
Like (0)
I've never tried making this with white fish. I don't know that the marinade would go well with it, and the pressure cooking time would need to be decreased. I recommend using chicken in this recipe, at least for your first try.
Like (0)
Does this work in an instant pot without adding additional water? I’m so exited to try it but I’ve read so many instant pot failures that didn’t use enough water and didn’t cook properly. Thanks in advance!
Like (0)
I've cooked this a number of times in a 6 quart Instant Pot and it works every time. If you use the correct amount of ingredients and follow the instructions, you should be fine.
Like (0)
My new Favorite...when planning my indulgent valentine’s for one, this was a must have!!
Like (0)
This recipe is absolutely fantastic. I have made it at least six times. I use yogurt made in my IP for the recipe!
Like (0)