Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

★★★★★

This was wonderful! Even my super picky three year old ate the chicken! This will be a regular at our house!
Like (0)
Just purchased an Instant Pot, and will be using it to make this dish. Question for the group: I plan on "Tripling" the recipe. How much additional "pressure" cooking should I plan on adding? Is there a Rule of Thumb when it comes to using these units, and increasing cooking times? Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.
Like (0)
Even though you're tripling the recipe ingredients, the pressure cooking time should remain the same. Let me know how it goes!
Like (0)
If I wanted to use boneless thighs, would I have to adjust pressure time?
Like (0)

★★★★★

This was delicious!! Omg, I could drink that sauce it was so good!!! I have an 8qt Instant Pot, so I doubled the recipe. I used chicken thighs instead of breasts because that’s what I had on hand, but otherwise followed the recipe exactly. Thank you so much for posting such a yummy recipe!!
Like (0)
Kristine

★★★★

I just made this, turned out so yummy and fragrant. I used four chicken breasts and replaced whipping cream with half and half, it worked out good. I think I’ll use fresh ginger next time, something spice wise was missing. I think I over simmered at the end because my chicken was a tiny bit over cooked. I only marinated the chicken for an hour, I wonder how tasty overnight marinating would achieve. Thanks for the recipe, I love my instant pot.
Like (0)
If I double the recipe do I change the cooking time?
Like (0)
I wanted to love this, but I am sad that I didn't. I think it's too much garam masala, so I will attempt again and cut it down to 1 teaspoon to see if we like it more. Will let you know :)
Like (0)
What brand of garam masala did you use? There can be a lot of discrepancy in spice blends between brands.
Like (0)
I used Penzy's. I'm trying it again tonight and I am going to cut the garam masala in half, see how we like it that way.
Like (0)
I am new to using an instant pot, Do you have to pressure cooker high and than Saute or is this either or? Thanks!
Like (0)
You should perform all of the steps in the recipe in the order that is listed. So you'll need to first marinate, then saute, then pressure cook, then saute. Let me know if that doesn't make sense!
Like (0)
InstantPot n00b

★★★★

Loved it! I used Penzeys spices which I've always found to be of great quality. The only change I would make is I would reduce the amount of fresh lemon juice in the marinade. It came through a little too much.
Like (0)

★★★★★

i’ve made this 4 times now and it’s a huge hit with all 5 members of the family. I double the chicken but keep everything else the same. I found doubling to sauce was too much. There is plenty to handle 2-2.5 lbs of chicken. Have used both whipping cream and coconut milk at the end and both work great. I usually just have coconut milk more readily on hand. Thanks for what is quickly becoming a weeknight staple!
Like (0)
I really enjoyed how simple this was to make and it gave my family a warm and comforting meal. Loved the complexity of flavors! I’ve made this twice now because it’s so easy to put together after a long day and the second time I added chickpeas for even more depth. Thanks for sharing!
Like (0)
I made this tonight and followed the instructions exactly, and the sauce ended up being a lot more sour than I remember from the Indian restaurant. Any recommendations on how to make the sauce less sour? Thanks!
Like (0)
Did you measure the lemon juice before adding it, or did you eyeball it? You could try simmering with additional heavy cream to mask the sourness.
Like (0)

★★★★

I made this today. Very new to instant pot cooking and ignored adding the cream after the fact. I got the BURN code but none the less the chicken came out great and I love the recipe. Will make it again and follow the directions properly.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I've been with my husband going on 21 years now. He said this was the best meal I ever made. Hands down.
Like (0)