Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Brooke Markley

★★★★★

This recipe is AWESOME! Such depth of flavor and very easy to make. This is being added to my collection of favorite recipes and I plan to make it again (and again!). Thank you!
Like (0)
Tara Browder

★★★★★

Delicious!!!!!! This recipe is definitely a keeper. If you wanted to make a bigger portion could you double this?
Like (0)
Hi Tara! Yes, you can double the ingredients, but keep the pressure cooking time the same.
Like (0)

★★★★★

My friend made this for me and it was amazing! I don’t have a pressure cooker though and would love to make it stove top. Will I just have to cook the chicken longer? Will the sauce be too thin? Any tips on converting this would be great! Thank you!
Like (0)
You have a great friend :) I have a version of this recipe for the stovetop: https://www.savorytooth.com/best-chicken-tikka-masala/
Like (0)
Hello! I attempted to make this recipe for dinner tonight and two times I encountered the “burn” message on my instapot. I released the pressure the first time and the bottom of the pot was indeed burned, so I cleaned it up and went for round two! The second time there was nothing burned on the bottom so I’m not sure why the message came up? Some reviews online said thicker recipes may cause this to happen but it seems like I’m the only one who’s had this problem with this recipie? Any advice? Thank you!
Like (0)
I think someone else had this issue as well. I would look into: - Did you forget to turn the venting knob to the sealing position? If the Instant Pot isn't sealed, liquid will evaporate and escape as steam, which means you will have a really thick sauce or not enough liquid in the pot, which can cause this error. - Did you use a 15 oz can of tomato sauce and not an 8 oz can? Sometimes people grab the wrong size, which means you don't have enough liquid in the pot. - Are you using plain tomato sauce, or tomato sauce with other additives? I recommend getting plain tomato sauce/puree. - Was the tomato sauce simmering after you added it to the pot? If you simmered the sauce, it's possible that it thickened and lost some volume, which can contribute to a burn warning. I recommend turning off the saute mode once you're done sauteing the chicken. That's all I can think of right now. Hope it's helpful!
Like (0)
My whole family LOVED this recipe! Very easy to follow instructions--thank you! Is there a way to make Rice using the Pot-in-Pot method with this? What about adding additional liquid and cooking it in the gravy? I'm still new to the Instant Pot craze.
Like (0)
Caroline

★★★★

I had the same problem with the burn sensor coming on. After a few starts and stops I switched the setting to low pressure and adjusted the cook time accordingly and it finished fine. Was super tasty. Just took a bit longer than planned and needed some baby sitting. I think the thickness may have been the issue. Will make it again now that I know I need to add some broth or adjust the time and pressure.
Like (0)

★★★★

I made this. The spices were delicious. But my chicken turned out dry and stringy. I’m nit sure what I did wrong. This is only my third time using the Instant Pot. Maybe I sauted too much in the beginning?
Like (0)
I didn't follow this recipe at all but I made it myself in a very similar fashion using chicken thighs. One thing they don't say, but plenty of other recipes and Instant Pot enthusiasts will, is that you definitely need to consider how much liquid is in the pot. The overall (can never go wrong) mantra is at least 1 cup of liquid but you don't need THAT much. I stuffed all of my chicken thighs in, along with the marinade I had in the bag with it overnight and all I did was add around a 1/4 to 1/2 cup of water in it. This isn't designed to be a specific answer to your question. More as a frame of reference towards finding it. You might have saute'd too much in the beginning. You shouldn't have to saute until it's cooked on all sides. Even if you sear, broil or saute something before hand, once you start pressure cooking, it'll get really wet anyways. I was able to cook my chicken thighs without saute'ing and it came out great. If you decide to do it with chicken breasts, just saute on a lower temperature for the same time or a higher one for a much shorter time.
Like (0)
I'm a newbie at using Instant Pot and this will be my first recipe to try. I only have a 3 qt pot. Would the ingredients fit? Should I change the time? Thanks!
Like (0)
Hi Maria! The ingredients should fit just fine, and keep the cooking time the same. Let me know how it goes for you!
Like (0)
Kandance Weems Norris
I am a pescatarian. Could I make this with shrimp or salmon instead of chicken? Would I adjust the cooking time?
Like (0)
I'm not sure how well the marinade would work with seafood. I would probably skip the marinade and the saute step, and pressure cook the sauce and seafood until cooked through, which won't take long for salmon or shrimp.
Like (0)
R. Wheeler-Birkenhead
Thanks for this fantastic recipe! Just had a spiced up vegetarian version last weekend. Everyone seemed to enjoy it to the utmost!
Like (0)

★★★★★

So so delicious! I made it tonight and we loved it:). My sister is a vegan-do you think we could replace the chicken with cauliflower or would something else work?
Like (0)
Glad you like it! I think you can replace the chicken with cauliflower, chickpeas, or tofu. You can replace the heavy cream with coconut cream. Hope that gives you a starting point!
Like (0)

★★★★

Try Indian paneer. In India, the paneer version is common for vegetarian eaters. Unlike tofu, paneer is made from milk and won't fall apart during the cooking process.
Like (0)
So...I think we need to discuss the definition of 'instant.' To most of us, 'instant' implies that you throw a bunch of stuff in a pot and rush back to the crying child and/or soccer practice. Multi-step preparation is not at all considered instant. I'm sure your recipe is amazing, but for me it's just click-bate.
Like (0)
Instant pot is the name of the cookware. Perhaps you need to bring this up to the maker of Instant Pot instead of baselessly calling a recipe click bait?
Like (0)

★★★★★

Made this tonight and it was WONDERFUL! Thanks for the recipe.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Made this today, and I followed the recipe exactly. It was fantastic! So delicious! Thank you so much for sharing your recipes with us. :)
Like (0)