Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings
I was really excited to try this recipe, but for some reason my pot never came to pressure. The chicken came out dry. This is the second time I used breast in the IP and probably the last. Thighs work much better. The taste was pretty good, but maybe a bit too much garam masala.
Like (0)
I'm not surprised the chicken didn't turn out well if your pot never came to pressure. My guess is that you didn't meet the minimum liquid amount for your pressure cooker. This amount varies by brand, but a safe amount is 1 to 1.5 cups minimum liquid. To increase the liquid amount, you can double the ingredients (but keep the cooking time the same).
Like (0)
I’m surprised how good the chicken breast was. When I’ve tried to cook chicken breast before in the instant pot, it came out chewy. But this was tender and moist, probably because of the yogurt marinade. Delicious recipe! Thanks!
Like (0)
If I weren't married, I would elope with this recipe and never look back. I'm always on the hunt for new meal ideas and this crossed my path today (since I just got an Instant Pot for Christmas). The kids devoured their first plate and went back for seconds, I was not-so-secretly angry that I wouldn't have leftovers for lunch because of my greedy little food-hogs, all the while wondering how soon is too soon to make it again. My crew had jasmine rice but I put mine over lightly steamed and diced cauliflower for a lower carb option. I also served a side of roasted green beans. Thanks, this was a fast favorite.
Like (0)
I don't have an instant pot..can I make this on the stove top or in the oven?
Like (0)
Yes! Here's the recipe for the stovetop version: https://www.savorytooth.com/best-chicken-tikka-masala/
Like (0)
Thanks for this recipe! It was my first time trying out my IP since I got it for Christmas. The taste was good and my chicken was moist! My only comment would be that the sauce was pretty gritty with spices. I think perhaps a little too much garam masala. I wonder if this would be good with a teaspoon or two less of garam masala? Also I will definitely double recipe next time as we have barely any leftover 😭 Anywho! I'm thinking "oh the possibilities" with this instant pot and this was a pretty good way to get this party started.
Like (0)
I've tested this recipe with various brands of garam masala and I like the amount used here and it never tasted gritty to me, but definitely use less if you find it to be too strong.
There are so many things you can make in the instant pot, so I'm glad you got to try it out with this recipe. If you love artichoke appetizers, I recommend this one: https://www.savorytooth.com/instant-pot-artichokes/
Like (0)
All in all a solid recipe. We all felt it lacked a sweetness so may try coconut milk instead of cream next time. I am so far loving the Instant Pot but this type of meal can just as easily and quickly be made on the stovetop.
Like (0)
You're correct that this can be made easily and quickly on the stovetop. That's actually how I originally made it, which you can find here: https://www.savorytooth.com/best-chicken-tikka-masala/
Like (0)
Can you make rice at the same time? Pip?
Like (0)
So I totally thought I had turmeric and I don’t. What could I substitute for it if anything? Curry? Thank you!
Like (0)
Hi Sara! I would suggest skipping the turmeric instead of trying to find a substitute. The taste won't be affected too much, but the orange color will be a different hue.
Like (0)
This was easy and amazingly good! Marinated the chicken overnight.
Like (0)
I made this recipe and love it. However during the pressure cooking my 6 qt Instant pot stated BURN. This was about 8 min into the cooking. Turned off and released pressure. Luckily my chicken was done so I proceeded. What can I do to alleviate this problem? Add water? Add more tomato sauce? Both my husband and I love this recipe!
Like (0)
The "BURN" warning means that the instant pot has detected a high temperature at the bottom of the pot so it suspends cooking. The best solution is to double the recipe's ingredients -- while keeping the pressure cooking time the same -- so that there is more liquid and even heating. Also make sure that all of the ingredients are well stirred before pressure cooking, so that there are no ingredients stuck to the bottom of the pot that can overheat and trigger the burn warning. Did you see anything burnt when you opened up the instant pot?
Like (0)
If I wanted to double this recipe how would I adjust he pressure cooking time?
Like (0)
Keep the pressure cooking time the same.
Like (0)
This recipe was amazing! I made the mistake of writing down the ingredients from the original recipe and then making it according to the electric pressure cooker version - so I used a whole jalapeno and it was real spicy. It was still VERY good, I am going to try it again this weekend according to the recipe and use the 1/4 teaspoon of cayenne. Thanks!
Like (0)
Glad you enjoyed it despite the spiciness!
My original stovetop recipe includes a jalapeno because I used to have a lively jalapeno garden and needed an excuse to use up my peppers. But nowadays it's way easier to just use dried spices like cayenne to provide some heat :)
Like (0)
Can the cream be substituted with half and half or whole milk to cut down in some of the fat?
Like (0)
I have never substituted with half and half or whole milk, but I know other readers have successfully substituted all or part of the heavy cream with those alternatives. Some even substitute with coconut milk. I think these alternatives would result in a less thick sauce, so I have always used heavy cream.
Like (0)
Use coconut cream instead of milk, much better for thickening. I think it would work wonderful!
Like (0)
That's a great idea, thanks for suggesting it!
Like (0)
This is the best tikka masala I have ever made! I did add extra spices because we like LOTS of seasoning! We will definitely make it again, and again! Thank you!
Like (0)