Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Josh Butler

★★★★

Very good recipe! I made it exactly as is and turned out great. It was plenty spicy for us but if you want extra spicy, go with another 1/4 or 1/8 teaspoon of cayenne.
Like (0)
I’m marinating the chicken as we speak for my first foray into using my instant pot! I have quadrupled the recipe for my family (we’re bif meat eaters and we like leftovers) but does the cooking time remain the same?
Like (0)
Yes, the cooking time for the pressure cooking part will remain the same. For the sauteing, it might take longer than 5 minutes since you're searing more chicken chunks. When you use the quick release handle, release it gradually and gently (careful, it will be hot!). Since you're using 4x more chicken and sauce, it might splatter a bit so that's why I would be a bit more careful using the quick release.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I have made this recipe about 10 Times now. I used crushed tomatoe and a curry paste instead of the seasons and it is by far my family’s favorite recipe currently. The instapot makes it so easy. Thank you for this!
Like (0)
You're welcome Kerryn. I'm ecstatic that your family loves this recipe so much :) Curry paste sounds like a great substitution for the seasonings!
Like (0)
I want to try this Tikka Massala in the instant pot tonight, can I make balsamic rice at the same time? Pot in pot.
Like (0)
This recipe isn't designed to cook both chicken tikka masala and rice in the same pot, so I'd suggest cooking them separately.
Like (0)
I made this recipe for my son and grandkids tonight. We really enjoyed it. I was wishing I had put just a bit more chicken in it. I had a lot of extra sauce left over. We found it to be delicious! Thanks for posting it out there
Like (0)

★★★★★

I made this and subbed out the Greek yogurt with homemade yogurt and coconut milk for the heavy cream due to dietary issues but it turned out great!
Like (0)
Hi Amanda - would you mind sharing your yogurt recipe? I am allergic to dairy - well and basically everything else lol - and when you substituted the coconut milk for the heavy cream - did you use the same amount/measurement that is in the original recipe Thank you - have a beautiful day!
Like (0)

★★★★

I made this tonight. It was good but just a little spicy for my liking, i might try adding a little more cream to mellow it down. (which may have been my own fault). Also after adding the cream i cooked it for 10 minutes and it didnt really thicken. Next time I will use tomatoe puree instead of sauce. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
Like (0)
If it looks watery after adding cream, the issue could be with your marinade. Did you precisely measure out all of the marinade ingredients? If you just eyeballed it, the marinade could be too watery and that extra liquid would result in a less thick sauce. I haven't seen much of a difference when using tomato puree vs sauce.
Like (0)
Can you make this with the rice in the pressure cooker? If so, how would you do it? I’m new to Instant Pot so trying to figure it all out—thanks!
Like (0)
If I want to add cauliflower and peas to this when should I do it?
Like (0)
Add cauliflower and peas after pressure cooking. When the sauce is simmering in Step 4, the cauliflower and peas will be cooking, and it'll be done once the cauliflower is tender.
Like (0)
Michelle

★★★★★

This is one of my absolute favorite Instant Pot recipes! It is amazing. Thank you for posting this!
Like (0)
Thank you for posting this recipe- I’m trying it tonight. This is also my first time trying instantpot, so wish me luck! My question- I had 2lbs Of chicken so I doubled the recipe. Will I need to alter pressure cooking time? If so, any recommendations?
Like (0)
Hi Addie! The pressure cooking time remains the same. Let me know if you have any other questions!
Like (0)

★★★★★

After reading through all of the reviews, I see you’ve addressed this multiple times. Thank you so much for quickly responding to my message despite this. It was absolutely delicious and was voted better than our local Indian food restaurant, so thank you for this keeper of a recipe. Like others commenting, i might need to tone it down a little next time with less cayenne and more cream, but big kudos to you.
Like (0)