Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings
Making this now. Chicken is in the marinade. Do I put all the sauce (a lot) in to sauté or just pull out the chicken pieces and whatever marinade sauce that’s on it, is what I use?
Like (0)
Looking forward to trying this recipe. Is there enough liquid? In the past with similar recipes I have had trouble with the “burn” message, has anyone had to add water?
Like (0)
Hi Lois! I use a 6 quart Instant Pot and I've never had trouble with pressurizing or burn messages. I don't recommend adding water because it dilutes the sauce. If you're worried, you can add a small amount of water (like 1/4 cup) and use the saute mode to boil it off at the end of the recipe.
Like (0)
I'm making this tonight. I was wondering if you put all of the marinade in? Or only what sticks to the chicken. Thanks.
Like (0)
Hi Sara! I only add the marinade that's sticking to the chicken. Hope you enjoy it!
Like (0)
do you have to add any oil before you cook the chicken
Like (0)
Hi Stacy! I don't add any oil before cooking the chicken.
Like (0)
Made this tonight for dinner. We were extremely excited and could not believe how easy & great this recipe was-thank you! We live approximately 50 miles from the nearest Indian restaurant, so this will be a mainstay for our family.
Like (0)
Loved the recipe. I didnt do the Saute portions in the InstantPot because the new ones throw a burn error and shut-off when using heavy stuff like sauces (really annoying). For the actualy pressure cooking portion I used the Pot-in-Pot method for the same reason.
For those having trouble with the manual mode described in the insteuctions, the newer InstantPot's don't have this function. Just press pressure button, and repeat pressing to toggle betweeb low, medium and high and then set the time for it. It works the same way.
Like (0)
Is there a non dairy substitute for the greek yogurt?
Like (0)
Hi Marlene! Some grocery stores sell non-dairy yogurt, like coconut based ones. If you have any health-focused markets near you, it might be worthwhile calling them to ask if they carry any non-dairy yogurt.
Like (0)
Has anyone tried it using brown basmati rice? If so what adjustments did you make to the time and liquid?
Like (0)
Tried this today and it turned out great. I followed the directions to the 'T' but the lemon juice was overpowering. I ended up adding a bit more cream, and a tablespoon of sugar to offset it. Will definitely try again, but perhas 1/2 the amount of lemon juice.
Like (0)
Making this tomorrow! I was thinking about sautéing onion and garlic before sautéing the chicken to add more flavor. Would that be okay? I also wanted to double the amount of chicken. Should I double the tomato sauce and spices as well?
Like (0)
Hi Yuri! Sauteing onion and garlic sounds great. If you double the chicken, you should also double all other ingredients if you want to maintain the same ratio of chicken and sauce. If you don't think you'll need that extra sauce, then you can only double the chicken.
Like (0)
Oh my goodness!! I made this tonight and I can’t believe how easy AND so delicious!!! This will be added to the dishes we love to eat!! Thank you for making me look like an amazing cook!😊
Like (0)
I saw someone mentioned onion.... I don’t see that in the recipe. I love onion and don’t want to miss out!
Like (0)
I love onions too! I actually don't use onions in this recipe, but it certainly wouldn't be a bad thing to add :)
Like (0)
OMGOSH! I made this exactly as directed in my Instant Pot ...it was fabulous! I’m already quite partial to Tikka Masala and yes, I too could eat this more than once a day. 5 stars overall for flavor and simplicity with The Instant Pot! Thank goodness for leftovers!!!
Like (0)
Thanks for your feedback, Robin! So glad to hear you loved it and found it easy to make. :)
Like (0)
I made this last night and the family loved the taste. My husband said it was a once a weeker! It did feel like there was way too much sauce compared to the amount of chicken, so next time I will try to reduce the cream and tomato sauce by half and see what happens. It also seemed like a lot of garam masala, so I will reduce this (we are a spice-loving family, FYI).
Like (0)
Thanks for your feedback, Rebecca! If you reduce the cream and tomato sauce, note that the decrease in liquid may make it more difficult for your pot to pressurize. If that's the case, you can add some water to aid in pressurizing, and then boiling off that extra water afterwards.
Like (0)