Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Hey! This recipe looks so good I'm making it as we speak. I just got a burn message on the first round of pressure cooking so i released pressure and added about half a cup of water and stirred it in. Hopefully i wont get the error again. This smells so yummy so i really want to enjoy it! I'm using a 6qt instant pot ultra so if you get a burn message try adding some more liquid. You can always reduce it when you do the cream at the end. *crosses fingers* so far so good!
Like (0)
Some readers have been getting the burn message. I believe some newer Instant Pot models are over-sensitive and throwing a burn error for thicker sauces even when there is no actual burning. So far I haven't been able to recreate the same error in my Instant Pot. Adding a small amount of water, like stirring in 1/4 cup of water to the sauce before pressurizing, should help with that.
Like (0)

★★★★★

The BURN message is annoying and is commonly caused from the fonds, the black bits that you scrape from the bottom of the pot during the deglazing process and after the sauté process. Just be sure that you get all of the fonds from the bottom and incorporate them into the sauce. I hope this helps.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Love this recipe! Even my two small children gobble it up. I'm planning to make it for 8 people in a few days. Any tips for doubling the recipe?
Like (0)
To double the recipe, just double the ingredients but keep the pressure cooking time the same. Let me know if you have any other questions. Hope everyone enjoys it :)
Like (0)
I love chicken tikka masala, but I am really sensitive to spice (what some consider "mild" is often still too spicy for me). When I order it from a restaurant, I request for it to be not spicy. Is it possible to remove the spice without losing the flavor? Would leaving out the Cayenne be enough or should I reduce the garam masala also? Thank you, in advance, for your help!
Like (0)
Hi Candice! I think it's fine to remove the cayenne entirely. Since you're sensitive to spices, I would cut down on the black pepper in the marinade by using only 1/4 teaspoon. For the garam masala, use only 1 teaspoon in the marinade and only 2 teaspoons in the sauce. That's what I would start with :) The color and resulting taste will be affected by the decrease in spices, but hopefully it will still be pretty good. Let me know if you have any other questions!
Like (0)
Ashley Davidson

★★★★★

My boyfriend loves Indian food and he has said at least 10 times while eating this that it’s so good. (He just said it again... I’m dying...). Thank you for making me look good. 🤣🙌🏻👏🏻
Like (0)
Hi I was just wondering if you could also cook your rice in with the chicken to make it truly a one pot meal?
Like (0)
Yes, I would use a pot-in-pod method. You would add another "pot" into the Instant Pot to cook your rice to keep it separate from the chicken and sauce. I haven't tested this before so I can't provide any more specifics, but that's the basic gist of it!
Like (0)
Can you recommend anything other than the cream? Half of us are lactose intolerant, but don't like coconut milk either... I know, we're difficult 🤣
Like (0)
Haha what do you guys think about almond milk? It's a bit thin compared to cream, but it might be your best dairy free alternative.
Like (0)
I used sour cream . They sell lactose free , or use more Greek yogurt , naturally lactose free
Like (0)

★★★★★

I don't typically write reviews, but this recipe calls for it. I made this last night using my Instapot for the first time. The meal turned out perfectly and tasted just as good as those we've found in our favorite Indian restaurant. My wife - the finicky eater - raved about it. I'll definitely be using this recipe again and again.
Like (0)
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review! I'm so happy to hear that you and your wife enjoyed this :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

Confirmed: this is incredible. I doubled the recipe, worked great in my 6 qt Instant Pot. I like it with a kick, so I used hot Hungarian paprika...and probably a little more than the recipe called for. I might even triple the amount of chicken when I otherwise double everything else next time. So. Good.
Like (0)
Hi Abby- My apologies, I never saw your reply until now. No, the cooking time doesn’t change, interestingly enough.
Like (0)

★★★★

I've made this twice, and each time I get the BURN warning. The first time it happened twice, even after I scraped the pot and added more tomato sauce. Any suggestions? The end result was fabulous, great flavour, but I'd like it not to take 2-3 attempts ;)
Like (0)
Hey Simone! If you look through the comments, some readers have been getting the burn message. Here's what I've said in the past: "I believe some newer Instant Pot models are over-sensitive and throwing a burn error for thicker sauces even when there is no actual burning. So far I haven’t been able to recreate the same error in my Instant Pot. Adding a small amount of water, like stirring in 1/4 cup of water to the sauce before pressurizing, should help with that." And another reader Marv has suggested: "The BURN message is annoying and is commonly caused from the fonds, the black bits that you scrape from the bottom of the pot during the deglazing process and after the sauté process. Just be sure that you get all of the fonds from the bottom and incorporate them into the sauce. I hope this helps."
Like (0)