Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

MillerTime
Do I add the marinade to the pot with the sauce?
Like (0)
You only add the marinade that's sticking to the chicken chunks. If you have leftover marinade in your bowl, there's no need to scrape it out and add it. Either way, it likely won't make much of a difference in the resulting dish.
Like (0)
Cambodia mama

★★★★★

I had no time a hungry family to feed. I thought this recipe may not be good bit it was quick and maybe it would resemble indian curry. I was so very happy when I tasted this delicious meal. I don't have time to marinate and it was still delicious! Also I don't have heavy cream so I just added sour cream and actually it was just as good a little bit spicy but delicious. Really happy ! Thanks for this recipe
Like (0)
Thank you for your feedback! It's so helpful to hear about recipe tweaks that work well :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

I’m a first time instant pot user and I made this dish and was blown away! There was so much flavor and the chicken was perfectly tender. My husband had seconds and literally drank the sauce. I don’t think he’s ever had this type of food before and we both loved it! And it’s gluten free-bonus!
Like (0)
Haha that's great!!! This sauce is so good that my husband also drinks the sauce and licks his bowl clean :) I've been telling people, chicken tikka masala is the kind of Indian food that EVERYBODY likes, even those that have never had Indian food in their life before!
Like (0)
Melissa Murray

★★★★★

Hi! I made this recipe last week for my family. My husband is a farm kid - a steak, corn and potatoes kind of guy - he won't even eat Chinese takeout. IT was such a huge hit, guess what I made for dinner last night? You guessed it... this... HE LOVES IT!! Now onto lunch... I am making your broccoli cheese soup. Thank you!
Like (0)
Haha I love this!! Thanks for sharing :) If you like the chicken tikka masala, I also recommend my chicken adobo (https://www.savorytooth.com/instant-pot-chicken-adobo/) and salsa chicken soup (https://www.savorytooth.com/instant-pot-salsa-chicken-soup/).
Like (0)
I made this today and both my husband and I loved it, we are used to really spicy/hot Indian food and this didn’t seem spicy at all to us. I see in the comments where people have mentioned it being on the spicy side too, what am I missing? Love the recipe though!!
Like (0)
I agree, it's not that spicy at all. Some people are just really sensitive to spices in general, or they may have made a mistake in the amount or type of spices they used. Who knows :)
Like (0)
Jessica Moore

★★★★★

I’ve made this three times and it’s huge hit! Thank you so much! Out of curiosity...Can you make the marinade a day in advance? Wasn’t sure if the lemon juice means same day only.
Like (0)
You're welcome, I'm glad you enjoyed this! I haven't tried making the marinade a day in advance, but I think another reader has done so and said it worked out well.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Made this tonight for the first time. My family loved it! Thank you
Like (0)
JustJayneIA

★★★★★

This recipe is AWESOME!!! I'm in love with Trader Joe's chicken tikka masala, and make a 40+ mile trip once a month to stock up. I've tried several different recipes but none of them really hit the mark until THIS ONE! I'm so glad I found this post. I've already made it twice this week. Yummmmm!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Delish! I used some canned coconut milk (the thick part) and then a splash of half and half at the end. I wound up cooking it 20 min instead of 10 because I had frozen the chicken after prepping it. Lots of fresh cilantro at the end is key. Thumbs up all around the table.
Like (0)
Thanks for sharing your experience! I like how you used the thickest part of coconut milk -- great idea!
Like (0)
This was wonderful. There is enough sauce I think you could use 1 1/2 lbs of chicken. Also think it would be great with chicken thighs.
Like (0)
Thanks for the feedback! I think chicken thighs sounds like a great idea. I'm going to try that soon!
Like (0)
I’m making this tonight but have a large family. I need to double the recipe but am new to the instant pot. Do I double everything?? Spices, tomato sauce, heavy cream etc? Thank you for your help!
Like (0)
Hi Crissy! I hope this turned out well for you! Yes, to double the recipe, you would double all of the ingredients, but you would keep the pressure cooking time the same.
Like (0)
Eileen Mace
Can I use almond milk instead of whipping cream?
Like (0)
You can, but I've never tested almond milk with this recipe. I suspect it might end up too thin. If you don't want to use heavy cream, you can sub with a combination of half and half, coconut cream, and/or coconut milk.
Like (0)
Heather Vanderbilt
Can I let this marinade overnight? I was going to cook tonight but something has come up....should I cook it anyway and just eat as leftovers??
Like (0)