Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings
Hi, Julia! I'm really excited to be trying this for a holiday party this weekend. I'm going to be doubling the recipe to feed a larger group. Should I increase the cook time at all in the instant pot?
Like (0)
Hi Carrie! The pressure cooking time should be the same, even if the ingredients are doubled.
Like (0)
This looks like a good recipe, but i'm left wondering why nearly every chicken tikka masala recipe online calls for the dish to be garnished with cilantro. I've tried nearly every recipe online that has decent reviews, and the one that most closely resembles the best chicken tikka masalas that i've had in restaurants is finished with fenugreek leaves, definitely not cilantro! Fenugreek leaves really make the flavors of the dish "pop"... it is the one necessary ingredient for a superb chicken tikka masala, and I wouldn't even think of making the dish again without it!
Like (0)
There is a difference between finishing with fenugreek and garnishing with cilantro. You can do both at the same time. It's my understanding that fresh (not dried) fenugreek can turn bitter when overcooked (which takes a matter of moments) so it is put in as a finishing herb sometimes. The dish is usually then garnished with cilantro. Pretty much every chicken tikka masala I've ever had (and I've had many, since my husband is Indian and it's my favorite dish. lol) has been finished with cilantro. Maybe the fenugreek vs cilantro garnish thing is regional?
Like (0)
That should have said "garnished" with cilantro, not finished. That was the whole point. Lol
I'll be trying the recipe tonight, by the way. :-)
Like (0)
Bren, I never thought of using both cilantro and fenugreek leaves, but I’ll have to consider doing that for part of my next batch.
I did get around to making this recipe a couple weeks ago with some minor modifications... and all I have to say is WOW! This is probably the most simple recipe for this dish that I’ve ever made, and it was easily one of the best, if not THE best I’ve had anywhere... including some of the best I ever had in restaurants.
Modifications were as follows:
Fresh, microplaned ginger for the marinade. I used quite a bit more than the recipe calls for. Probably close to 2 tsp. I also added another 1 tsp or so to the sauce. Every sauce I’ve ever made has ginger.
15oz can of tomatoe purée, plus another small can of tomatoe sauce, and maybe another 1/3 cup of water to thin the sauce down a little.
After pressure cooking I let it cook a little longer to thin down the sauce to desired consistency.
1 medium sized jalapeño for the sauce microplaned with no seeds instead of the cayenne. This turned out to be the ideal amount for me regarding heat/sweet balance of the dish. Not overpowering at all... while not being to weak either, letting the sweetness of the tomatoes define the dish. It was just right.
Fenugreek leaves to finish, no cilantro.
I also used a “new to me” garam masala bought at an Indian grocer.... I think this made a big impact too.
The result was nothing short of excellent! I think I’ve finally found the holy grail of recipes for this dish. Much thanks to Julia for this recipe!
Like (0)
If I need to serve 8, how would you adjust the recipe?
Like (0)
Double the ingredients, but keep the pressure cooking time the same.
Like (0)
Can I use chicken thighs? I prefer them to chicken breasts
Like (0)
I haven't tried thighs with this recipe, but I think that would be fine. Use boneless and skinless ones.
Like (0)
Really great and easy recipe to follow! I haven't tried making Indian food before, but this made it a breeze. This seemed heavy flavor-wise on garam masala for my liking, but I think that has more to do with the spice that I bought than this recipe. I would definitely make this again. Thank you!
Like (0)
I am planning to make this recipe tonight, can I substitute the whipping cream with coconut milk?
Like (0)
I've never tried that because I like my sauces on the thicker side, but I know other readers have and enjoyed it with coconut milk/cream.
Like (0)
Thought this recipe was very good. I added some crushed red papper to the sauce and used mostly half and half. I will def make this again.
Like (0)
I made this last night. I was afraid to use 1/4 tsp cayenne, but ended up adding more after cooking because needed more kick.
I also added about 1/4 cup of real butter.
I didn’t have heavy cream, so I warmed up/reduced 1.5 cups of half and half and that was fine.
Family loved it, but as mentioned, since I had only used 1/8 tsp of cayenne, I ended up adding more at the end.
Like (0)
Question - I also used butter and half and half, but it doesn't seem to be getting thick. Any suggestions? Did yours thicken?
Like (0)
Made this for the family last week & they loved it! Making it again this evening for company. A must try!!
Like (0)
Wow! You guys are tough! I thought I would get on here and have everyone say it was way too spicy! I put in 1/2 of the cayenne this recipe called for and my mouth was on fire! I have little kids so they all ended up eating pb&j for dinner. I love the recipe otherwise!
Like (0)
Yes this was very spicy and I didn’t even add the cayenne!
Like (0)
This was delicious. Based on another recipe that didn’t quite convince me, I added cauliflower and peas and cooked on high pressure another 2 minutes. Amazing. So looking forward to leftovers tomorrow
Like (0)
Made this with double the cayenne and the spice level was perfect for me.
Like (0)
Would this freeze ok? Just worried about the cream...
Like (0)
Made this last night and served it over Jasmine rice ... my family LOVED it!
Like (0)
I made this and it was ah-mazing! I added a few veggies to the sauce prior to cooking in the Instapot and they were great! I also subbed coconut milk for the heavy cream which gave it a great nutty flavor :)
Like (0)
Hi! Did you put in the same amount (1 cup) or did you adjust the ratio? Making this for the first time.
Thanks for your help!!
Like (0)