Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

★★★★★

So so amazing! Loved all the extra sauce!!!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I made this but subbed the masala seasoning (my grocery store was sold out) for curry powder...oh my god it was so good. hubby raved!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Simple and delicious - just as good as takeout! I followed the recipe exactly and served it over cauliflower rice. The spice level was perfect. I will be making this again for sure!!
Like (0)
Hi, how can we make this less spicy?
Like (0)
To make less spicy, reduce the amount of cayenne and black pepper. If you can't handle any heat at all, chicken tikka masala and other Indian recipes may not be the best choice for you.
Like (0)
Grupgirl

★★★★★

I've made this twice now - and it turned out delicious both times! I noticed the first time I made it I had a LOT of sauce left over, so the second time I added 3 diced potatoes (at step 3). The potatoes cooked perfectly and went so well with the dish. I also picked up the microwaveable basmati rice to save time - it worked great. This is my new favorite IP recipe!
Like (0)
Kristin Freitekh

★★★★

Made this tonight it was great by oh my was it spicy!! I knew 1/4 tsp cayenne pepper would be too much for my family so I only did the slightest sprinkle of it but it was still too much. My 8 year old couldn't eat any of it but my 12 yr old & husband powered through it lol. I had to serve more yogurt as an additional topping to help cut the spice. My question is was that just the cayenne responsible for that heat or is it also the masala seasoning? It's my first time using garam masala so I'm unsure.. Will definitely make again & cut back on the spice level! Thanks in advance!
Like (0)
The slightest sprinkle of cayenne -- spread out among 4 servings -- shouldn't have such a strong effect. I think it's the garam masala and/or black pepper. If you try this again, skip the cayenne entirely and only use half of the listed amounts for garam masala and pepper. Hopefully that'll make this recipe more in line to your tastes :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

This came out delicious!! Any recommendations for a vegetarian version?
Like (0)

★★★★★

Excellent. We tried another recipe first, it was watery. This one was wonderful!
Like (0)
Samantha Waite

★★★★★

So good! I wanted a recipe to try out my new instant pot (yay!) and this was perfect in so many ways! Quick and very easy recipe that even a newbie like me could follow. And so flavorful! All the spices in this were delicious. I was a little skeptical about how much tomato there was, but it turned out great, not too tomato-y at all. And the spice was just right. I was worried it wouldn’t be enough (I’m from New Mexico.) but this was just perfect. Nice and flavorful with just a bit of a kick to it. Thank you so much for the wonderful recipe. Definitely saving this one!
Like (0)

★★★★★

My first recipe EVER with my new IP... boyfriend and I ate every last bit! We didn’t find it too spicy at all and ended up adding a little extra of each spice, we will be hands down making this much more in the future. Thank you so much.
Like (0)
I'm planning on making this for 4 adults and 2 children...if I double the amount of ingredients do I need to add more time to the pressure cooker?
Like (0)
Amy Fucci

★★★★★

ok this was absolutely DELISH!!! however, i do eat indian food a lot, and this was definitely spicier than any i've had before. and i only added 2 tsp of garam masala to the sauce. im not sure what the discrepancy is between people's reviews on this and the spicyness. maybe it depends on the type of garam masala you use? next time, i'll do half the spice and add it in later if needed.
Like (0)
Yeah, I'm seeing very bipolar reviews on how spicy this is. For me, it's only mildly spicy, and I've tested this recipe with different garam masala brands.
Like (0)
Instant pot chicken tikka masala!!! I'm Always looking for new instant pot recipes. Looks great, am planning on making it. Is there any way to substitute yogurt for the heavy cream?
Like (0)
We made this recipe tonight and loved it, but it seemed very watery! What did we do wrong? There was already alot of water when we started to add the sauce ingredients, so maybe it was our chicken or too much of the marinade went it? The cream didn't thicken it up much at the end.
Like (0)
Sounds like your chicken was too moist. If you make this again, pat the chicken dry with paper towels before combining with the marinade.
Like (1)

★★★★★

The first time I made this recipe it was very watery as well and I had to simmer it for a while. I would suggest a combination of 15 ounces of tomate puree and tomato paste vice the tomato sauce! I've cooked this numerous times now and did that instead and it did not turn out as watery!
Like (0)