Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings
I've made this 5 or 6 times, and it's always amazing. Can you use chicken thighs instead of chicken breast?
Like (0)
I haven't tried chicken thighs with this recipe before. Hoping someone else will chime in with their experience.
Like (0)
I use chicken thighs, it comes out fantastic. I use 12 minutes instead of 10.
Like (0)
Great. Thanks for letting us know, Jacob.
Like (0)
This recipe is phenomenal.. I’ve made it 6 times .. quick question — how much is one serving? I saw the nutritional info but no actual serving size.
Like (0)
Hi Steph! The number of servings is listed above the recipe's Ingredients list -- it says 4 servings. So the serving size is one quarter of the entire recipe. The nutrition information is for one serving.
Like (0)
This is by far my favorite recipe for my instant pot! I have shared it with so many friends and colleagues over the past several months, and it’s definitely become a regular on my family’s dinner rotation. I sauté an onion with the cloves of garlic before browning the chicken, but otherwise, I follow your directions to the letter. Thank you so much for this fabulous recipe!
Like (0)
Loved it. Made it exactly as per recipe except used boneless skinless thighs (because I prefer dark meat). I simmered for at least 10 minutes at the end because the sauce was a bit liquid. I might use more chicken next time because my husband prefers more meat. Served over riced cauliflower. The garam masala I used didn’t have “spice” in it, so the dish was mildly spicy.
Like (0)
That is what the cayenne pepper is for. Just double or triple that up
Like (0)
Hello,
Learning to cook, and trying with this recipe. With the pressure cook step, it doesnt mention adding water. Just want to doublecheck if this is correct, or if the minimum amount of water for the instapot should be added.
Like (0)
It's correct -- you do not add water. If you do, you will end up with way too much extra water in your sauce. Unlike other modes of cooking, pressure cooking retains almost all of the liquids in the added ingredients.
Like (0)
Great recipe the whole family looooooved it. Thank You!
Like (0)
My family and friends love this dish! The recipe is super easy and fast. Thank you!
Like (0)
If I wanted to sweeten the sauce up a bit with coconut milk, would I add it before pressure cooking or with the cream at the end?
Like (0)
I would add it at the end. I recommend substituting part of the heavy cream with coconut milk, as opposed to just adding coconut milk. Otherwise you might end up with too much sauce.
Like (0)
Makes sense. Thanks!!!
Like (0)
Made this recipe and turned out excellent! Perfect sauce to chicken ratio and definitely flavorful!
Like (0)
This looks delicious and the recipe seems very easy to follow. We just purchased our Instant Pot and I'm so intimidated I haven't even unboxed it yet! Did you cook the rice in the Instant Pot as well?
Like (0)
I typically cook the rice (or cauliflower rice for a low carb option) separately.
Like (0)
Do you add the rest of the marinade to the pot after you brown the chicken or just discard it?
Like (0)
I discarded the rest but I actually used the marinade to marinate 2 lbs of chicken and doubled the rest of the recipe. There wasn’t much yogurt waste when I did this. I could see where a cup would be too much for one pound of chicken!!
Doubling the rest allows you to use the large can of tomato sauce and a full pint of cream so nothing is sitting around waiting for you to cook again. (The large sauce is 29 ounces instead of 30, but it was fine).
Like (0)
This was very good. I substituted a can of full fat, unsweetened coconut milk for the heavy cream and added it up front. It thickened up quite a bit, but maybe not as much as it was supposed to (I've never had or made this dish before, so I can't judge). I think next time I'll add a diced jalepeno pepper and sauteed onions. I was unable to find brown basmati rice, so I served it with couscous. This is only the second recipe I've made with my new Instant Pot, and it was a success! Thanks!
Like (0)
Can you marinate overnight?
Like (0)
Yes, that should be fine.
Like (0)
Seems like a simple enough recipe. Perfect for breaking in my Instant Pot! Thanks, Julia!
Like (0)