Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Do you think I would be able to sub coconut yogurt for Greek yogurt and coconut milk for cream to make this Kosher?
Like (0)
Many readers have subbed coconut milk for cream and liked the results. I'm not sure about the coconut yogurt though -- I'm hoping other readers can chime in on this.
Like (0)

★★★★★

This recipe was delicious so much so I made it 2 nights in a row, spice heat was just right for me, Marinated the chicken in a vaccum pac bag for around 2 hours and used smoked paprika.
Like (0)
This was SO GOOD!!! It was so good that as soon as I finished eating it, I had to tell everyone else I know with an instant pot to make it! Seriously so easy and so tasty!
Like (0)
Jackson Simpson

★★★★★

So good !!!
Like (0)
I tried another IP recipe for tikka massala and constantly got the "burn" error. I was reading that tomato-based recipes in an instant pot tend to do that. Do you ever have issues with this recipe and dealing with the "burn" error?
Like (0)
Some readers have an issue with burn errors. I've tried to investigate the problem by testing on different IP models, but I've never been able to replicate the burn error. I think some newer models have higher sensitivities. To reduce your chance of getting a burn error, I would make sure that the pot is scraped clean before pressure cooking (i.e., use a stiff wooden utensil to loosen any browned bits on the bottom of the pot).
Like (0)

★★★★★

This was the sh**! And very easy to make! I did chicken thighs, no yogurt, and used unsweetened coconut milk mixed with a little tapioca flour for thickening, and added a bit more sea salt at the end. Definitely will make again! And perhaps add onion and green peppers.
Like (0)
Courtney

★★★★★

I am so thrilled with this recipe! Recently moved from a large city to a small town of less than 2,000. While I love the country, I desperately miss the ethnic foods! This recipe is better than the carryout I used to order. Planning to make in batches and freezing for my mom nights! Thank you for sharing! You made my day!
Like (0)
Forced Vegetarian

★★★★★

This recipe is SO GOOD. I make it all the time, I love it. I'd like to make it for some family who is visiting soon, but one of them is a vegetarian. Would you know if I need to adjust anything substantially if I subbed the chicken for paneer or tofu?
Like (0)
Take a look at this recipe (https://www.savorytooth.com/cauliflower-curry/) which is a vegetarian version made with cauliflower.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I absolutely love this recipe- so much that it’s not enough! Do you have any tips for doubling the recipe in the instant pot?
Like (0)
Hi Blair! You should be able to double the ingredients, keeping the pressure cooking time the same.
Like (0)

★★★★

Hello we love this recipe at my house but I never can get it to thicken up :/
Like (0)
Try boiling it for a longer period of time until it's noticeably thicker, stirring frequently.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Absolutely delicious! I'm a big fan of cooking Indian recipes and this one is a true keeper!
Like (0)
Hi! You probably won't see this in time, but I'll try asking anyway... when you add the chicken to the IP do you add ALL the marinade with it or just the chicken (with marinade ON it)?
Like (0)
Just the chicken with the marinade on it. It shouldn't make a huge difference either way.
Like (0)
There shouldn't be much marinade left over, so I typically discard the rest because it isn't much. If you have a large amount left over, you can either (a) discard, or (b) add the leftover marinade at the same time that you add the sauce ingredients prior to pressure cooking, so that it'll just become part of the sauce. It's up to you. It shouldn't make a big difference either way. Hope that clarifies this!
Like (2)
Instant pot fan

★★★★★

This recipe is awesome. Who knew Indian food could be so easy to make and yet taste so good ? I love to eat this using my homemade yogurt and homemade naan.
Like (0)
Nikhil Das Nomula

★★★★★

This recipe is delicious!! I mean I was surprised that it turned out so good. Thank you so much for sharing this. If anyone wants to try, I highly recommend this recipe.
Like (0)
Rebecca S.

★★★★★

Absolutely delicious. Made as written. Garnished with limes, cilantro and grilled naan brushed with olive oil. Thank you so much for the recipe!
Like (0)
I'm new to the IP world. I have a bigger family, so I will double (or maybe even triple) this recipe. In step 3, when I "select manual mode to cook for 10 mins at high pressure," should I increase this time if I've doubled or tripled the recipe?
Like (0)
Hi Anne, keep the pressure cooking time (10 minutes) the same, even though you're doubling or tripling the ingredients.
Like (1)