Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Can I freeze this after I make it?
Like (0)

★★★★★

I freeze this often. I use coconut milk instead of the heavy cream so I am not sure if that would make a difference. It freezes and re-heats great. This is one of our favorite recipes.
Like (1)

★★★★★

We meal prep this and freeze with rice in individual meals, no problems from us! :)
Like (1)
I haven't tried freezing this, but I think it will turn out okay despite the dairy content.
Like (0)

★★★★

Thank you for this recipe! I love indian food. Made exactly as described except couldn't find 2% Greek yogurt so used whole. It came out a little sour so I am planning to cut back the lemon next time. I will also be adding more cayenne for personal taste as I like things spicy. I did have a problem getting the sauce thicker at the end, sauted for about an hour and just didnt notice any thickening but still tasted great and I love all the sauce this recipe makes for eating with rice and naan! I did feel it had a touch of something missing and I like the suggestion of adding a little butter to try and give it that more creamy fullness taste from my favorite indian restaurant. Will definitely use this as the core structure when I make this many more times and just tweak it for personal taste. Thank you!
Like (0)
This recipe looks easy and yummy. I want to make this tonight or tomorrow but only have about 1/4 cup Greek yogurt. Can I use sour cream or something else in place of the 3/4 cup yogurt? Or is that going to make a huge difference? Thanks!
Like (0)
Chrissy Fitch

★★★★★

Our favorite meal, we make it once a week.
Like (0)
Christina Clements

★★★★★

So, if this is the ONLY dish I make with my instapot, I will have considered it a great investment. I love this dish so much. I have left out the lemon juice before by accident and it was still fine. HOWEVER...has anyone tried to double it in the instapot? I am having a bunch of people over Friday and would like to serve it, but I am still not familiar with the pressure cooker. Would you straight double it or just add more chicken? Thoughts?
Like (0)
You should be able to double this by using 2x ingredients and keeping the pressure cooking time the same.
Like (0)
Jeffrey Eyerly

★★★★★

I added a pinch of ghost pepper flakes for extra kick. It worked. The recipe turned out great.
Like (0)
Danielle Tanner

★★★★★

We. Love this recipe! I usually double the amount of chicken for my family. We are having a friend over that is vegetarian. I've seen a lot of Tikka recipes with checkpeas. Do you think I'd need to change anything to substitute the chicken for chickpeas? Thanks!
Like (0)
I'm glad you enjoyed this recipe! I haven't tried using chickpeas before, but an older comment from a reader named Kirsten said that she added chickpeas and it worked out well. I don't think she made any other changes. Besides chickpeas, you can also try cauliflower or extra firm tofu. The main thing to watch out for is any differences in cooking time. Hope that helps!
Like (0)
Kaitlyn J.

★★★★

I haven’t made homemade chicken tikka masala in years and we just got a new instant pot so I figured I’d give this a try! It was personally my first time using the instant pot so I was a little intimidated but the recipe and instructions are very straightforward making it really easy to make. However, I burned the some of the chicken and the marinade that got stuck to the bottom of the pot. I may be dense here- but should I have used a cooking spray or oil before putting the chicken in the pot? It wasn’t in the instructions so I didn’t, but I really don’t want this to happen again! Luckily the sauce had a couple of minutes to pressure cook before the burn message came on so I think I salvaged it by quick releasing and then simmering and adding the cream. It’s a little smokier than I think is intended but at least I didn’t have to throw it all away! Also, my husband and roommate will love this because of the extra kick from the cayenne but I’m not as fond of spicy food so I would omit it next time. Otherwise DELICIOUS!
Like (0)
Thank you for your feedback, Kaitlyn! You aren't being dense -- there isn't supposed to be any oil that you need to add beforehand. I'll make a note to update this recipe with more clear instructions. Glad you were able to salvage it!
Like (0)
We also had this problem. We had to pull it out of the instapot and cook on the stove. Should we have added water or something?
Like (0)
Is the bottom of your pot deglazed? Before pressure cooking, I would make sure that the bottom of the pot doesn't have any browned bits stuck to it, which may lead to burn errors during pressure cooking. You can deglaze by using a stiff wooden spoon to loosen the browned bits (adding a bit of water may help loosen them as well). Please let me know if you try this again and deglazing helps solve your issue.
Like (0)
Hi Julia, I made this recipe again tonight before I saw your comment. I didn’t specifically deglaze the pot, but there were no brown bits or anything stuck to the bottom of the pot. I did use a little cooking spray this time and at first it seemed promising but then as soon as the pot got up to pressure, it cooked for about 1 minute then I got the food burn message again. I released the pressure and opened it up and the whole bottom of the pot had a layer of what looked like burned marinade on it. Because I had the cooking spray down it did seem to scrape off easily but all of my sides were done and I didn’t want to try to preserve those while waiting for the pot to get up to pressure so I just stirred in the cream and simmered. The taste is still ok but the texture could be a little better. I just don’t know what I’m doing wrong :(
Like (0)
Thanks for the detailed feedback, Kaitlyn; it's very useful as I'm trying to figure out why some readers have a burn issue and others don't. Since you mention the burnt marinade as what likely triggered the burn message, here are my thoughts: (1) What is the consistency of the marinade? It should be pretty thick, coating the chicken well. I use the Fage brand for plain Greek yogurt. If your marinade is a bit thin-looking, pat the chicken chunks dry with paper towels to make sure they're not contributing liquid. (2) How thoroughly are you stirring the sautéed chicken with the sauce ingredients, before pressure cooking? I would make sure that the sautéed chicken is not directly in contact with the bottom of the pot, to avoid burning. It's possible that adding a bit of water (2 to 4 tablespoons) to thin out the tomato sauce may help. If you try any of these suggestions, I'd love to hear how it goes for you.
Like (0)
I have had the burn message twice now but not ready to give up on the Instant Pot! I scraped the bottom each time and the second time I’ve added about a cup of water and it’s working!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Hi Julia! Okay, so tonight I tried this recipe for the third time. This is the easiest tiki masala recipe I have found and I refuse to give up! I think I finally got it! I used almost two pounds of chicken this time around. I'm cooking for three and we like to have leftovers when we can and I found that one pound of chicken just didn't do it for us. I did not double the marinade and it was still plenty to coat all of the chicken. Because I used more chicken and am lazy and didn't want to brown the chicken in batches, I browned the chicken in a large skillet. While the chicken was browning, I mixed the sauce in the instant pot. When the chicken was done, I put it into the instant pot and mixed everything together. I set the instant pot for 10 minutes on high. Right when the pot got up to pressure, I got the "food burn" message. As I angrily stomped over the counter, the message went away and the icon disappeared from the screen. I watched it intently and the food burn message never showed up again. When cooking time was up, I let the pot naturally release for 2 minutes (I was tending to rice, bad timing) and then quick released the rest. After adding the cream, I let everything simmer for about 5 minutes. I FINALLY DID IT!!! I made this recipe with nothing getting burned and it was AMAZING. Though I dirtied an extra pan by browning the chicken, it was worth it. Yay!
Like (0)
Great!! Thank you for sharing your experience. I'm happy to hear that the skillet browning step worked out for you :)
Like (0)
I am going to try this recipe tonight. Do you think it would help to just cook the chicken in another pan first and then transfer it to the pressure cooker? I have often had issues with the burn message with thicker sauces, so I am trying to avoid it all together. Thanks for any feedback!
Like (0)
Since you often have issues with burn messages, I think it would help to cook the chicken in another pan first and then transfer it to the pressure cooker. I hope this turned out well for you!
Like (0)

★★★★★

My first time using a pressure cooker and this was delicious and easy. Thank you.
Like (0)