Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala
Discussion & ratings
687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings
Not bad. Probably a little too much garam masala in there since the cinnamon flavor was a bit overpowering compared to what I'm used to. The sauce was definitely runny and did not thicken up at all at the end, even after over 5 minutes of simmering, but that was easy enough..just serve in a bowl. I added a few tablespoons of butter at the end based on reading some of the other comments. Overall I do feel like the dish is missing something. Onions perhaps? I will keep searching for my perfect tikka masala at home. My chicken did not come out dry or problematic at all like others commented. I used tenderloins (exactly 1lb) and pretty much dumped in all of the marinade.
Like (0)
So you added butter and all of the marinade and you’re surprised your sauce was runny?
Like (11)
This was so good! I heavily recommend this recipe for first-time users; I often mess up recipes but this was quite easy.
I added chickpeas during step 4, just before adding the heavy cream and simmering. I served with rice and naan bread.
Like (0)
This was the first Instant Pot recipe that I’ve tried!
The instructions were great and easy to follow, and the food delicious! I’ve made this a few times. This last time I cut the garam masala in half; it was a little too sweet for our tastes. My husband requests this dish often!
If I double the recipe, do I need to double the time as well?
Like (0)
Thanks for the feedback, Kira. If you double the recipe, the pressure cooking time remains the same.
Like (0)
I tried to make this and found it to be way, way, way over spiced. Either I made an error, which may be likely, or this is just a super spicy dish. I haven't found that to be true at Indian restaurants, but they could have been Americanized.
Like (0)
My family doesn't like spice so I leave out the cayenne pepper entirely. It also depends on the Garam Masala you chose. Some have cayenne, some don't. They're not all made the same! I personally make my own blend.
Like (0)
How do you make your own blend?
Like (0)
Is the marinade a must? I’ve made this dish several times and it’s delicious!!! I don’t have time for a 1 hr marinade right now though!
Like (0)
I'm excited to try this! If I use thighs, do i still have to saute?
Like (0)
Yes, I would still saute if you're using thighs.
Like (0)
It's really good (I quadrupled the cayenne and added a 1/4 tsp of ghost pepper powder so it'd have a little kick to it).
Like (0)
My husband and I make this as a staple for our dinner rotations! We make it exactly as the recipe calls. Love this so much!
Like (0)
Can I leave out the Greek yogurt in the marinade? I’m dairy free and plan on using coconut cream instead of whipping cream.
Like (0)
I don't recommend leaving out the Greek yogurt. It would be better to replace it with a dairy-free Greek-style yogurt, either coconut or almond based.
Like (0)
This is restaurant quality good! So amazing! All 7 of us loved it. That's a huge success!
Like (0)
Is there any way to make use of the marinade? Maybe by adding it to the sauce?
Like (0)
Yes, you may add any leftover marinade at the same time as the sauce ingredients.
Like (0)
My husband loved it, said it tasted very close to our local Indian take out place. Will be making this again. Had no problems with burn notices. May try this with a different gram masala :)
Like (0)
My daughter (11) is super picky. She loves this recipe. And us too! She likes it better than the restaurant version! We make it a couple times a month. Super easy. And very tasty!
Like (0)
The flavours were good but overall a disappointment. I followed the recipe precisely but the chicken was dry and there was twice as much sauce as needed.
Like (0)
We love this recipe! We get the burn message almost every time I use the Instant Pot but I have no issue cooking it in our Ninja Foodi.
Like (0)
Taste restaurant quality and so easy to make!!! I always make this with 2 ingredient homemade Naan. Everyone I have cooked this recipe for has loved it. Usually I have to tweak a recipe to make it better, this recipe is great as it is!!
Like (0)
I LOVE this recipe. It was a hit with my family and even our extended family at a reunion. I am wondering though - would it freeze well? I often see it as a freezer meal in stores, but store bought never tastes as good as this recipe. So I’m wondering if I could stock up on it as a homemade freezer meal… Has anyone had success with that? Would love to know how you did it if you have!
Thank you for this recipe regardless!
Like (0)
Yes, you can totally freeze this. I portion the leftovers and take them to work. I use a mini crock-pot lunch warmer and it works GREAT! Such a good recipe!
Like (0)