Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

★★★★★

Outstanding. I have been making this for a while. My 2 adult sons request this every time they visit, no more trips out to the local Indian Restaurant. I think I need a bigger Ninja Pot! There is never enough! This is our family favorite and it is SO easy. Thank you for this, I am getting ready to start a pot now, it smells so lovely. :-)
Like (0)

★★★★★

My kids LOVE this recipe. I have made it so many times. It never disappoints. Only Garam Masala available in the grocery store is Private Selection (Kroger) and it's good. I usually double the chicken.
Like (0)
Anna Gilley

★★★★★

I have made this twice and loved it both times! Is a hit with the whole family. The recipe is so easy but the flavor is so rich and it looks like your a gourmet chef.
Like (0)

★★★★

Why did I get the burn signal? I followed the recipe, which was delicious! I had to finish cooking it on the stovetop. Next time I will have to eliminate the cayenne - my husband is a wimp!
Like (0)

★★★★★

This is fantastic recipe that my 2yr old absolutely LOVES. One question though, can the sauce be frozen and served at a later date? I didn't want to ruin a full batch if freezing it would change the flavor/consistency.
Like (0)
Jasmine Roberts

★★★★★

I’ve tried a number of Indian recipes and they never measure up to restaurant quality. This one does! The only change I would make is to drain the excess liquid after sauteeing the chicken, because I felt like it watered down the sauce a little. I added some extra cayenne and it was a perfect kick. Definitely will make this again!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I love this recipe so so so much. Probably one I make the most in my IP. Only thing I've noticed is the garam masala you use really matters in the final outcome. I've made this with different garam masalas in a pinch before and it was lack luster. I'll only use the one from Pinch spice market since it's well balanced blend. A previous one I picked up randomly I felt had too much cinnamon or something else and made it overly sweet.
Like (0)

★★★★★

I absolutely love this recipe. One I make the most in my IP. To the people getting burn notices, I would check the size of your instantpot. I use an 8 qt one and I have to double the recipe in order to meet the liquid requirements required for it. I've never received a burn notice making this.
Like (0)
Hi Sarah - when you double the recipe, do you double all the ingredients? I need more food for my hungry young men, and want to know how to adjust. Thanks!
Like (0)
Ugh. I LOVE this recipe and how it turns out (eventually) but I get a BURN notice on my instant pot. Every. Single. Time. I have tried sautéing the chicken in a separate pot, then generously spraying the instant pot insert to avoid sticking. No idea what to do. Any tips gratefully received. My sister in law is Indian and I have been cooking curries for years, but it’s is by far the best! If I can only get it to STOP BURNING! 😩
Like (0)
Carrie, do you use an 8 qt Instant Pot? If so, I wonder if it would help if you doubled the recipe's ingredients so that there is more overall liquid inside the pot.
Like (0)
I recently started having the burn error too and I don't know why. I've made this many times over the last several years and am puzzled as to what changed. I have always used jarred pasta sauce and I see that the recipe now says to only use canned sauce. Would that make a huge difference?
Like (0)
My guess is that jarred pasta sauce has more water content than canned tomato sauce, and that could make the difference.
Like (0)
Nancy Robbie

★★★★★

Made the Recipe it's wonderful!
Like (0)
Julia - when you double the chicken, do you double all other ingredients as well?
Like (0)
Jocelyn Alfaro

★★★★★

This was sooooooooo good! I never post any reviews and this I had to. Super easy to make and instructions were on point. You just gained a follower. I even Had Indian lounge music like if it was a restaurant. Haha 😂 recommend 10/10
Like (0)

★★★★★

This is my favorite Instant Pot recipe! So easy and delicious! I make a homemade Garam Masala because I have all the spices that make up the mix. And I always leave out the cayenne pepper because my kids can't handle any heat. There's so much flavor! Love it! Made it many, many times now!
Like (0)
This is a great recipe, and I enjoyed using all of the spices! I followed the recipe step by step, but somehow mine turned out super bitter. I feel like it had to have been the tomato sauce I was using. Maybe it was the brand I used (canned, no salt added, Hunts brand). I really don't know, but something was off. I'm not sure if anybody else has had this problem or if anybody has any suggestions on what it could have been. I could taste all of the flavors, but the overwhelming bitterness killed it for me. I ended up adding a tablespoon of unsalted butter, dash of ground cinnamon, and I'm going to guess about 1/4 cup of loose, light brown sugar (I didn't measure, just kept sprinkling in until I got the flavor I was looking for). I sautéed in the IP for a few min, and the bitterness was completely gone. This ended up turning out to be a beautiful dish! I'll definitely make again, but I'll try using a different brand of tomato sauce next time.
Like (0)
It is bitter because you used canned tomato sauce (per instructions). Make your own tomato sauce from peeled San Marzano tomatoes (28 oz can cooked on med-low for 25 minutes w/ quartered onion and 5 tblspoon butter). There are simple 3 ingredient recipes like this to make appropriate tomato sauce. This will eliminate the sour hint in your sauce. Otherwise, great recipe.
Like (0)
Meredith

★★★★★

My husband and I make this almost weekly. We love it! We actually make this rather than going out. A fantastic recipe!
Like (0)
For me as a pretty new cook I was confused on what was the marinade and what was the sauce. I did it wrong and I’m pretty sure it won’t work out for me. Maybe for others who are regular cooks and who cook Thai foods this would be a given, but it wasn’t for me. If it had been labeled “Marinade” instead of “Marinating Chicken” I would have likely not gotten confused. Oh well, it looks like other people really enjoyed it! Thanks
Like (0)

★★★★★

I thought it was weird to saute the chicken with the marinade, too, so I didn't. My chicken was cut up into bite sized squares. I poured the whole bowl with the marinade and the chicken into the pot, and then poured the sauce on top. I pressure-cooked on high for 10 minutes then did a NR for 10 more before quick-releasing the rest of the steam. What an awesome recipe!! We served ours over plain spaghetti squash, because that is what I had.
Like (0)
Elizabeth

★★★★★

For busy weeknights, I make a basic version of this by skipping the marinating step and placing diced raw chicken in the pot with the other base ingredients before pressurizing. The chicken cooks fully in the allotted time and comes away with the flavor of the sauce it's immersed in. Our whole family loves it! (I put a bowl of coconut rice in with the chicken to cook at the same time.)
Like (0)