Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Neil McDonald
Can I switch out the heavy whipping cream for coconut cream? thanks Neil
Like (0)
I have 7 people to feed, does this double okay? I have a the IP duo (6 quart).
Like (0)
Doubling the recipe would work for 7 people as long as you also have plenty of rice and/or naan to go with the sauce.
Like (0)
Can I use half and half instead of heavy whipping cream?
Like (0)
I haven't tried using half and half so I'm not sure how it would turn out. If you give it a try, let me know!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I have used half and half several times and it's still absolutely delicious! My kids (8 and 10) beg me to make this meal - it's an all time fave!
Like (0)
Okay, I'm super excited to make this. Just bought the rest of the ingredients yesterday. I'm curious: can the chicken be marinated overnight? I have something already for dinner tonight, but have the chicken in the refrigerator and don't want to freeze it, so was going to go ahead and put it in the marinade, but thought overnight might be too much?? Thank you! (I know this post was a while ago - I hope you are able to read and answer soon! Or anyone who knows!) :)
Like (0)
I really wanna try this. Had been years since I had my last chicken tikka. Will be using Noxxa pressure cooker.
Like (0)
I think it's only a little spicy, but that's just me. You can omit the cayenne completely if you're worried about the spiciness level.
Like (0)
i have been coveting this recipe for weeks, and finally made it last night and i'm not sure what happened! it was more of a brownish red and the garam masala taste was very very strong (i bought the one you linked to on amazon) i followed the recipe exactly except for ONE thing: i used half and half instead of heavy cream, but in the end i also ending up adding sour cream because it was still very strong and not that beautifully yellow tumeric-like color at all. we all still ate it and it wasn't bad, just wasn't the authentic tikka masala taste we were expecting. i will try again, this time with paneer cheese and try to figure out what went wrong :)
Like (0)
Oh no I am so sorry to hear that!! There seems to be a lot of variation in garam masala blends. Can you try using heavy cream instead of half and half next time? I am wondering if that was the issue.
Like (0)
I had the same issue. Mine is a brownish red and not turmeric yellow. I used Garam Masala which I purchased from the Indian grocery here. Color wise, my spice is the same as the one linked in he recipe. But I’m not sure of the spice ratios in mine. I also used half and half. I think I will use coconut cream/milk next time. Did you attempt this again with heavy cream and see a difference?
Like (0)
Just about every Indian recipe I've seen calls for frying the powdered spices in a bit of oil or ghee (clarified butter) first. It changes the character of the spices - softening the sharpness. I suspect that this may help tremendously. Just be careful not to burn the spices. You can find many examples of proper frying Indian spices on YouTube. I would suggest after sauteeing the chicken and before step 3, keep the pot in saute mode and put the dry spices in with a little bit of oil and fry in in until the "sharpness" of the aroma changes to something a mellower. Add a teaspoon of water periodically if you're worried about burning. Then proceed to step 3. I'm trying this method today.
Like (0)
Christian

★★★★★

Hi there, Huge Indian food fan (well, chicken tikka masala + naan fan) and my wife ordered me an Instant Pot for Father's Day. This was the first recipe I tried with my new machine! Turned out wonderfully! I typically eat chicken tikka masala without a fork.. because I make the naan do its job :) So I appreciated the sheer amount of sauce this recipe made. Taste was the best at-home taste I've made. And color / consistency was pretty good. I did add some corn starch at the end to help thicken things up a bit. Thanks for the thorough directions.
Like (0)
I'm flattered that my recipe was the first one you tried with the Instant Pot! And I can so relate to what you mean about having the naan do its job, sopping up the sauce with naan is the best part :)
Like (0)
Laura Lenz

★★★★★

OK...so I made this EXACTLY as you wrote it and...it was amazing!!! (Ok, I lied. I added extra chicken and maybe just a splash more heavy cream..but that was only to get a bit more sauce since I added more chicken and I didn't double the saucy part of the recipe.) For those who had possible issues with their Garam Masala, I can tell you that I bought mine from Sprouts. They sell spices in bulk so, you can buy exactly what you need. I got the tumeric, and the ground ginger there too. The color of the recipe was spot on and the flavor was fabulous! All I can say is THANK YOU! It smells (and tastes) like a fabulous Indian restaurant in my house right now!
Like (0)
Yay I'm so glad that you loved it!! I wish I had a Sprouts near me just so I could get their spices :)
Like (0)
Any chance you could convert this to a slow cooker recipe for me please? ???
Like (0)
It's definitely on my to-do list! A lot of people have been asking for a slow cooker version. :)
Like (0)
Ann, here's the slow cooker version: https://www.savorytooth.com/slow-cooker-chicken-tikka-masala/
Like (0)