Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

★★★★★

This recipe was spot on and fabulous! The flavor was equal to or better than the multiple step non-instant pot recipe that I've used. The only change I made was to pressure cook the chicken for 6 minutes instead of 10 and it came out tender and perfectly done. This is a keeper recipe!! I will definitely make this again! Thank you!!
Like (0)
I've never doubled a recipe for my pressure cooker, do you just double the cook time as well?
Like (0)
Hi Whitney! I haven't tried doubling this recipe before. In general, when you double a recipe for the pressure cooker, you should not double the time. If anything, I would suggest using less time (like 8 minutes instead of 10), because if you double the recipe then the cooker has more contents and will take longer to come to pressure, and the food is already cooking during that time. Let me know how it goes if you try it out!
Like (0)
Hello! This recipe is absolutely fabulous. My family, even my toddler, loves it! Unfortunately my fingers slipped when I tried to five star it and it gave it to three. I don't know how to change it?! Do you know how I can switch it to a five star? Thanks so much.
Like (0)
Hi Jade! I'm so glad that your family loved the recipe :) I'm unable to modify users' star ratings, unfortunately, but don't worry about it and thanks for letting me know!
Like (0)

★★★★★

This recipe is amazing! I substituted coconut milk for the heavy cream and it was delicious. My husband loved it too. Thanks for sharing.
Like (0)
My family loves Indian food! The only problem is my daughter and my husband are lactose intolerant. I saw other comments about using coconut milk instead of the heavy cream, but is there a substitute for the yogurt in the marinade? More coconut milk? I would love to make this recipe soon. Thanks!
Like (0)
Does your grocery store offer soy, coconut, or almond based yogurts that are dairy free? Unfortunately, I can't think of anything else that would work as a good yogurt substitute.
Like (0)
I was able to find soy plain Greek yogurt. I'm cooking this recipe tonight, so I'll let you know how it. Turns out!
Like (0)
So just got myself an Instant Pot, thanks to Amazon Prime day, and this is the first recipe I've tried. Thanks Julia it was delicious, will be doing it again for sure, it's a keeper. Do you have an Instant Pot Butter Chicken recipe by any chance?
Like (0)
You're welcome Louise, glad you liked it! I don't have a butter chicken recipe on the site, but it's on my list of things to make! :)
Like (0)
Excellent thanks for taking the time to reply, that's very nice of you. I'll stay tune for upcoming recipes. :)
Like (0)
Julia, Do you think I can freeze part of the chicken marinade prior to cooking, then let thaw in the fridge when ready to cook and follow rest of recipe? I had to use 3.5 lbs of chicken and it's all marinating in a huge bowl right now with triple the marinade ingredients LOL. I will make at least one pot tonight!
Like (0)
Hi Paul! That's a lot of chicken! :) This recipe makes a lot of sauce relative to the amount of chicken, so for your next pot, you can probably double the chicken amount to use it up and it'll be okay. I haven't tried freezing the marinade before so I'm not sure how it would turn out. Hope that helps!
Like (0)
It was very good but came out a little sour.. should I ask dad sugar or something else to balance the sour and sweet? Thanks!
Like (0)
There's a lemony taste to it but shouldn't be overly sour. Maybe it's the yogurt that you used?
Like (0)

★★★★★

Delicious! Trader Joe's has a garlic naan in the frozen section that was SO good with this!! Making it again and again!
Like (0)
YES!! I literally just had Trader Joe's frozen naan last weekend with this chicken tikka masala. It took about 5 minutes to bake and I used it to soak up all of the sauce. My husband likes naan a lot better than rice so it worked well :)
Like (0)
Im wondering why so many people want to substitute the heavy whipping cream? Is it flavor or calories. I made it tonight and it was very good, but husband did say something was off compaired to restaurant and we cant seem to put our finger on what it is
Like (0)
Hi Heather! I think it's because of the calories, perceived unhealthiness of heavy cream, or lactose intolerance. As for the flavor, you can try substituting the cream with coconut milk to see if it makes a difference, or use a mixture of both. I like using heavy cream because it makes the sauce thicker, but it's not for everyone :)
Like (0)

★★★★★

I made this last night and the only change was to use whole milk yogurt instead of Greek (it's what I had on hand). Everything else I followed exactly. The spice amounts and combination are spot on. What a delicious meal! I'm pretty excited to have leftovers here at work for lunch. I can't wait! Thank you for sharing.
Like (0)
Hi Caren! I'm happy to hear that it turned out so well for you :) Glad to know that whole milk yogurt works fine. Enjoy those leftovers!!
Like (0)