Comments on Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

← Back to Instant Pot Chicken Tikka Masala

Discussion & ratings

687 comments · 4.74 / 5 from 227 ratings

Hi there. Just got this recipe from a friend and very excited to try but I don't have a pressure cooker. Have you been able to translate to a slow cooker yet?
Like (0)
Hi Kate! I've made chicken tikka masala in a slow cooker but it doesn't look or taste as good -- the chicken really needs to be sauteed and you can't do that in a slow cooker. If you don't have a pressure cooker, you can make the stovetop version: https://www.savorytooth.com/best-chicken-tikka-masala/
Like (0)
Hi Kate! I just published the slow cooker version of this recipe: https://www.savorytooth.com/slow-cooker-chicken-tikka-masala/ I hope you get a chance to try it out!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I absolutely love this recipe! The last 2 times I made this the sauce seemed a bit granulated. Any ideas what could cause this? Thanks!
Like (0)
Hi Vanessa, thanks for your comment :) I haven't noticed any granulation in the sauce -- perhaps it's a difference in the garam masala being used? I've noticed that there can be a lot of variation in garam masala brands.
Like (0)
I was guessing that it was related to the yogurt. Maybe the brand I used or that the temperature changes affected it somehow. I'll try another brand next time and to not pour all of the marinade in to sauté with the chicken.
Like (0)
Ah, that could be it. I usually don't add the rest of the marinade in; I only include whatever marinade is sticking to the chicken, which is most of it. Hope it's less granulated next time!
Like (0)
Looking at this recipe....the only liquid is tomato sauce? Will pressure be created without burning? Thanks!
Like (0)
The minimum amount of liquid for my pressure cooker (Instant Pot) is 1 cup, and 15 ounces of tomato sauce yields more than 1 cup of liquid. I have found it to be sufficient and haven't had any issues. Hope that helps answer your question, and let me know if you have any other questions!
Like (0)
I accidentally added the cream to the marinate...what should I do? I was planning on letting it sit overnight in the refrigerator and cook tomorrow. Looking forward to your reply!
Like (0)
Hi Nicole! Personally, I would redo the recipe by starting over. If you'd like to preserve what you already have, I would suggest straining out the cream, if possible. If that doesn't work, just leave the marinade as is, and just make sure you don't include any of the cream when you add the chicken to the pot. Hope that helps!
Like (0)
I love all the comments! I am making this tonight and I have 2lbs of chicken. Do I need to add more spices and sauce or will it be ok? I am also a little worried as usually chicken breasts do not turn out that good in the IP so I typically use thighs.
Like (0)
Hi Erin! I don't think you'll need to add more spices and sauce for 2 pounds of chicken, since this recipe makes a generous amount of sauce. You might want to add a little more Greek yogurt for the marinade so that there's enough to cover all of the chicken chunks, like maybe 1.5 cups instead of 1. But it'll probably be fine either way. Hope you give it a try, and let me know if you have other questions!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I made this tonight, (with 2lb of chicken and 1.5 cups of yogurt.) It was absolutely lovely. My wife and kids also loved it and this is sure to be a new favorite. Thank you!
Like (0)
WE're going to be making this soon as well. I figured what some others have said which is that I'm going to double all of the ingredients so that we can make more use of the Instant-pot and have left overs for a few days. You think I'm okay to just double everything, sauce, marinade and chicken? It can't mess it up right? Just more of the good stuff to spread around.
Like (0)
Hi Eric, yes that's fine if you would like to double the ingredients. Are you planning on using the sauce for anything else, like naan or rice? If you aren't, you might end up with too much sauce, so I wouldn't double the sauce ingredients. Hope that makes sense, and let me know if you have any other questions!
Like (0)
Hello, I am excited to try this. Could coconut milk or cream be used in place of the yogurt?
Like (0)
Hi Laura! The marinade consistency would be very different if you used coconut milk or cream, so I don't think that would work. If you're looking for a dairy free alternative, does your local grocery store sell soy or coconut based yogurts? I think that could work.
Like (0)

★★★★

Thanks for the recipe! Followed everything to the tee and it turned out pretty good. Normally when I get chicken tikka masala in Indian restaurants I get some serious heart burn afterwards, and did not feel that way after this meal. That's the good, however, I do think the restaurant version tastes more buttery which I believe I missed that flavor in this recipe. What are your thoughts on adding perhaps half a stick of butter to the first saute?
Like (0)
Hi Sasha, thanks for your comment! I think that adding half a stick of butter to the first saute would work fine. If you give it a try, let me know how it goes!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Delicious and so easy! I used chicken thigh and added peas after cooking was done. Do you think I could triple the amount of chicken and would I have to double the sauce ingredients?
Like (0)
Hi Irene! Peas are such a delicious addition. Yes, I think tripling the chicken and doubling the sauce ingredients would work well. Make some rice or heat up some naan flatbread to go with it too :) I like Trader Joe's frozen naan.
Like (0)