Comments on Peanut Butter Cookies

← Back to Peanut Butter Cookies

Discussion & ratings

106 comments · 4.35 / 5 from 55 ratings

★★★★★

These cookies are delish, but unfortunately, the erythritol gave my husband and I severe GI issues. Would pure Monk-fruit drops work in this recipe? Since it would be missing substance, wasn't sure if I should add something in its place. Any feedback would be much appreciated. Thanks.
Like (2)
If you use pure Monk Fruit drops, I would add more (about 6 tablespoons) dry ingredients to make up for the lack of dry sweetener bulk. I'm thinking ground flaxseed, unflavored protein powder, ground pecans, or extra almond flour. Or a mixture of the aforementioned; my only concern is that they will add an unwanted taste or texture to the final cookies (e.g., the cookies may taste too strongly of flaxseed or almond). Also, keep in mind that the nutritional makeup of these cookies will be impacted, if that's of concern to you. Another option is using a dry sweetener that isn't erythritol-based, possibly Monk Fruit In The Raw, which is a dry sweetener that measures the same as sugar and Swerve. You can find more information about it here: https://www.amazon.com/Monk-Fruit-Raw-Sweetener-Ounce/dp/B00BMAGFCO
Like (4)
Thanks, Julia. Unfortunately, the Monk Fruit in the Raw has Maltodextrin in it, which also causes GI issues for us. I think I'll try adding flax-seed or ground walnuts or extra almond flour. Thanks so much for your response.
Like (2)

★★★★★

Made these today and they are delicious . . . Thank you!
Like (1)

★★★★★

Oh my!! Been craving peanut butter cookies. Tried several keto recipes an they were awful, but these are Amazing! After seeing 30 plus high ratings I figured I would give them a try. Quick easy but most of all DELICIOUS! My son said these are a keeper. Thanks for sharing your recipe!
Like (1)

★

I don't know how this recipie has so many good reviews. I just made this trying to find a good dessert for my dad and brother for Christmas (they are both diabetic) Thank God I tried the cookies a few weeks before I made them at Christmas because they were so dang dry and bland. I followed the recipie to a T. Using the swerve and coconut flour. Even went out and bought the necessary ingredients because I didn't have them on hand. Would not recommend. 😭😭
Like (1)
Damn Daddy
Great cookies! I’ve been playing with variations of a similar recipe for a couple years now: * I’ve found Almond Flour works best. I was surprised to find Cashew Flour didn’t work well, but both texture and taste weren’t as good. * Allulose sweetener tastes most natural to me. It’s not quite as sweet as sugar alcohol-based sweeteners, but the next addition more than makes up for that. Plus allulose doesn’t affect my stomach like erythritol can. * Add 2 Tablespoons Buttermilk Powder - Helps the Almond Flour hold the cookies together, also adds an extra burst of sweetness and a creamy-yet-crumbly texture. Adds about 1/2 gram of carbs to each cookie, but so worth it. * Dash of vanilla extract or caramel flavoring! * Sugar-free Baking Chips - A handful or a whole bunch! Make sure the chips don’t use Maltitol as a sweetener, as it’s not a low-carb substance. Or just follow the simpler recipe above. It’s already delicious without messing with it!
Like (1)

★★★★★

How much Swerve would you use?
Like (0)
I'm always using liquid stevia as I can't find any powdered stevia in Germany and I don't want to eat sugar alcohols. It works just fine!
Like (0)
Sue Davidson Griffore
Would peanut flour work for the cookies?
Like (0)

★★★★★

I used Lakanto Monkfruit Sweetner but only used 1/3 cup-I prefer less sweet. They were so good my teenage son ate some!!
Like (0)
Justice Devine
I'm curious if I can use Stevia? If so how much?
Like (0)
I have truvia packets, can I use this and how many packets would I use?
Like (0)
Jw Toole
Mine seamed a little dry anything I can do to Moisten them up a bit?
Like (0)
It's a weird thing but if you can get a piece of bread from a non keto person, put it into the container with the cookies and they will moisten up.
Like (0)
Use one of those clay things they make for keeping brown sugar (or sukrin gold 😉) from drying out. No carbs or gluten to worry about in those and they are reusable!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Very tasty, they turned out great!
Like (0)
Tj smith
Can I make this with almond butter instead of peanut butter?
Like (0)

★★★★

I just made them with almond butter. My diet is very restrictive and I cannot have peanuts, so......I am happy to say they turned out wonderful! A bit harder to mix I think than the peanut butter, so I added a tablespoon of liquid. Thank you for the recipe Julia!
Like (0)

★★★★★

Great recipe!!! Easy to make and taste oh so good!
Like (0)

★★★★

These cookies are overall good, a little dry and a lot crumbly but i put them in a bowl with some almond coconut milk and they were great. Give them 4.5 stars
Like (0)
Stefanie Lohrey

★★★★★

Just made these cookies, they were very good! I used a natural peanut butter that is a little more oily so I added a little extra almond flour for more of a cruchy crumble. XO
Like (0)