Comments on Peanut Butter Cookies
← Back to Peanut Butter Cookies
Discussion & ratings
106 comments · 4.35 / 5 from 55 ratings
Hi, made these. They were really good, a little dry but next time I will add the vanilla to see if that helps and I used no sugar at all. Both my husband and I loved them. He is not one for sugary sweets and me being diabetic. Just easier to stay away from it. Thanks for your recipe! 🙂
Like (0)
This is the first time I have heard of eyrithitol, can you explain what you mean by a cooling effect? What happens?
Like (0)
The cooling effect is an aftertaste in the mouth when you consume erythritol or baked goods with too much erythritol in them. You shouldn't taste them in this recipe or any recipe that uses a proper amount of it. I buy erythritol on Amazon and it comes in granules so I powder it using my Nutribullet blender before using in this recipe.
Like (0)
I use "Swerve" brand which comes in a "confectioners" or powdered form. Maybe plain erythritol is cheaper . . . I also use "Lakanto" which comes in a brown sugar type variety. Both of these also use monk fruit.
Like (0)
What is another flour that would be used if you are allergic to Almonds? Just about every recipe uses Almond Flour :( And if you have any great choices for sugar substitutes that would be great as well.. Thanks in advance :)
Like (0)
Hi Anissa! I've edited the recipe to include measurements for coconut flour. For sugar substitutes, I recommend pure erythritol as well as erythritol blends from brands like Swerve and Lakanto.
Like (0)
Try sunflower seed flour. Most people are allergic to nuts and they don't know it FYI. I grind my own sunflower seeds and it works amazingly as a substitute.
Like (0)
Fantastic recipe! Thank you! I'd like to try them next time without the erythritol. Should I modify the other amounts to maintain consistency in the dough? ie: more almond flour or something? Thank you for any advice!
Like (0)
Hi Jackie! I'm glad you liked these cookies. If you're planning on skipping the erythritol, I would add more dry ingredients to add bulk to the cookies, such as almond flour, coconut flour, or even whey protein.
Like (0)
I loved this recipe. I even shared it with my family and many of them thought the cookies were even better than the real thing. By far, this is the best peanut butter cookie recipe I have ever used.
Like (0)
These are so delicious and very simple to make!! My 6 year old never knew the difference
Like (0)
Has anyone tried these with an egg substitution like a flax egg?
Like (0)
I thought they were a bit crumbly and dry, but my daughter liked them a lot. I followed the recipe to a T, but the coconut flour may have gotten more packed down than the author of this recipe had. So it could have been my error.
Like (0)
For best results, use the weight values if you have a food scale. Then it won't depend on how you pack the coconut flour.
Like (0)
I used the coconut flour method and my dough was also WAY too crumbly, so I added an extra egg. They turned out perfectly!! And I DID weigh my egg first (50g out of shell). So yummy! Everyone loved them :) Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!!
Like (0)
Can you use peanut butter protein powder instead of real peanut butter?
Like (0)
I used the peanut butter powder although they did not turn out as cookies, it was more of a cake batter. So I bake them in a small lasagna pan for about 30 minutes. I topped them a handful of Lily’s chocolate chips and chopped walnuts. So ended up as squares but still good. Once cooled put them in the fridge to firm up. So glad I am still able to enjoy, I just ate one and oh so good 😋
Like (0)
Made this recipe, did not have parchment paper. Use cooking spray, at 12 minutes the bottoms browned too much and I gave it kind of a burnt taste. Could be the difference of simply parchment paper or something not on point with the recipe
Like (0)
The use of cooking spray will accelerate browning, which is likely why yours browned too much.
Like (2)
FANTASTIC and freeze well!! I, too, halved the sweetener and have used both almond and coconut flour and they're both great! Thank you so much for sharing :-)
Like (0)
Can you use monk fruit in the raw for the sweetener instead of erythritol?
Like (0)
Yes, that should work. Monk Fruit In The Raw measures the same as sugar. Since Swerve measures the same as sugar (and pure erythritol doesn't), you should use the amount listed in the recipe for Swerve, not erythritol.
I'm not familiar with the fineness of Monk Fruit In The Raw, however. For ideal cookie texture, I would use a Nutribullet or similar small blender to pulverize the sweetener into fine, powder-like consistency. This will help it incorporate better into your cookie batter.
Like (0)
I have Natreen liquid stevia, how much would you recommend using for this recipe? Excited to try it!!!
Like (0)
Does it say on your stevia's packaging how it measures compared to sugar? I would use an amount comparable to 6 tablespoons sugar.
Also, I would add some extra dry ingredients to maintain the ratio of dry to wet ingredients in this recipe. Take a look at another recent comment by a reader named Karen. In that reply, I provide a list of options to help with this issue.
Like (0)