Comments on Peanut Butter Cookies

← Back to Peanut Butter Cookies

Discussion & ratings

106 comments · 4.35 / 5 from 55 ratings

Steve Grabinski

★

Unfortunately was a crumbly mess. Followed recipe to the letter, cookies never browned, checked at 8/10/12 minutes. Took out and let cool. Cookies crumbled into dust at the slightest touch. Batter did taste good, better off making the batter and freezing for a treat
Like (0)

★★★★

Note - if you use a scale to measure your ingredients, the amount for peanut butter is way off. One cup equals 128 grams (not 260) so half of what is called for. Otherwise, a great recipe.
Like (0)
Not according to my peanut butter's label, which says 2 tablespoons is 32 grams. There are 16 tablespoons in a cup, so that means 1 cup is 256 grams.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Made these with coconut flour and swerve, following recipe exactly and they were yummy! Thank you for sharing the recipe!
Like (0)

★★★★★

I made these today and they were pretty good. I used 3 TBsp of swerve confectioners and 3 TBsp of swerve brown sugar and added a TBsp of butter also after seeing another comment here. I let them cool on the cookie sheet for 5 mins before moving them to the counter to cool completely. They didn’t crumble at all. So good..thank you.
Like (0)
So good!

★★★★★

This recipe turned out amazing and so good. Because I’m allergic to corn and a lot of the replacement sweeteners have corn I had to use organic vanilla coconut sugar. I did add vanilla, a pinch of salt, and some baking soda per another recipe I was looking at.
Like (0)
I don't like artificial sweeteners either and they don't like me! Did you use any confectioners sugar or just substitute granular coconut sugar? What amount did you use? Thanks!
Like (0)

★

I wanted these cookies to come out like the ones that I baked pre-keto. Unfortunately, they didn't meet expectations. I even tweaked it by adding a tbsp of butter like one of the commentor suggested. They still turned out dry and crumbly. I probably should have tried to add some heavy cream like another commenter had suggested. May try again with a few more tweaks since i love PB cookies but as for now, I wasted half of my peanut butter on something I can't bare to eat. Bummer!
Like (0)

★★★

I made these. They were yummy but crumbly and dry. I’d add heavy cream and maybe butter next time to see if it makes it better.
Like (0)

★★★

this was good, but like some said WAY too sweet. tasted like sugar cookie with a peanut butter after taste i'll try using half the amount suggested like one viewer said.
Like (0)
Did you use unsweetened natural peanut butter and the same brand of sweetener as indicated in the recipe? Different sweeteners vary in their sweetness as well as the type (powdered/confectioners vs granulated).
Like (0)

★★★★

Good but maybe too much of the sugar? It left an after taste.
Like (0)

★★★★★

Made the coconut flour version. Didn’t have powdered swerve so used 1/4c truvia. Turned out great!
Like (0)

★★★★

I made these delicious cookies and they came out very crumbly, yet still soft in the middle. I would like to know if there’s anyone who may have a tip on how to prevent them from falling apart like dust. I have photos, too!🤓
Like (0)
Just made these cookies but sub peanut flour for the almond flour - they are very good - as close to my old peanut butter cookies that I made pre-Keto.
Like (0)

★★★★★

The cookies were good but I also added 3 tablespoons of heavy cream to make sure they didn’t fall apart! I am so glad I read all the reviews!
Like (0)
Julia moss
what can you use in place of the egg for the peanut butter cookies.
Like (0)

★★★

Perhaps it's because I used 'natural' pb with the oil (one jar had oil on top, the other was mixed). I don't know. Followed the recipe and directions. I used coconut flour, excited to find a recipe that didn't use expensive almond flour. Recently made pb cookies with almond flour that were good (held together) but expensive to make. But, sadly, these are a super crumbly mess. I've only baked half the batch. I don't even want to bake the rest. I had intended to give half away to a neighbor but they are broken and crumbly. Sad. Used 2 full jars of pb. Need to start over! Going back to almond flour, I guess. The crumbs taste great, but you can't give cookie crumbs away.
Like (0)
Nidhi K Kalra

★★★★★

Thank you! Great recipe. Makes irresistible cookies. I only had chunky unsalted peanut butter so I added a bit of salt but they turned out delicious.
Like (0)
I made this with granular Swerve, came out very sweet. Next time I’ll definitely only use half the amount. Otherwise cookies were good.
Like (0)
Granular Swerve and Confectioners Swerve (used in this recipe) measure differently because the former is more compact and the same amount in terms of volume will be much sweeter. They can't be substituted for each other if you're measuring by volume.
Like (0)

★★★

Easy to make and great flavor. They look moist enough but seem dry as swallowing. I used the coconut flour and confectioners swerve. Guess they’ll be a good dunking cookie. This is my first time baking with coconut flour or almond flour. Would they come out less dry tasting if I used the almond flour?
Like (0)
It's possible that you would get better results with almond flour, but instead of replacing the flour, I think an easier modification is adding more peanut butter. The extra fat in the peanut butter will make the cookies taste less dry. Another thing you can do is underbake them slightly, so that they are more moist in the center. Hope that helps!
Like (0)